Freund Vanessa Lea, Peeters Frenk, Meesters Cor, Geschwind Nicole, Lemmens Lotte H J M, Bernstein David P, Lobbestael Jill
Department of Clinical Psychological Science, Faculty of Psychology and Neuroscience, Maastricht University, Maastricht, Netherlands.
Front Psychol. 2022 Oct 11;13:914270. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.914270. eCollection 2022.
Grandiose narcissistic traits refer to exploitative and arrogant attitudes, while vulnerable narcissistic traits entail hypersensitivity to judgment and low self-esteem. Little is known about how individuals with narcissistic traits can improve their attitudes toward themselves and others. The current research puts self- and other compassion forward as possible targets to alleviate some of destructive patterns of narcissism. Generally, self-compassion (SC) has previously been associated with beneficial effects on psychological wellbeing, while other compassion (OC) is advantageous for interpersonal relationships. This study explored the relationship between narcissistic traits and the efficacy of experimental compassion inductions. Student and community participants ( = 230, = 27.41, 65.2% female) completed grandiose and vulnerable narcissistic trait, SC and OC state questionnaires, and either an SC or OC induction. It was expected that individuals with higher narcissistic traits (particularly grandiose traits) would benefit from the inductions and show higher SC after but would have greater difficulty showing meaningful increases in OC (especially OC directed at the general population). The results indicated that individual differences in grandiose and vulnerable narcissistic traits are related to the magnitude of improvements following the inductions: the theorized lack of SC in individuals with vulnerable oversensitivity to judgment traits seems possible to be counteracted through different types of compassion exercises. Moreover, higher grandiose exploitativeness-entitlement and global vulnerable narcissistic traits related to less increases than others. However, directly inducing OC in individuals with these traits was linked to greater OC improvements than improvements after inducing SC. Overall, the present findings suggest that self-compassionate behavior can be improved in individuals with high oversensitivity and that other compassionate behavior could potentially be increased if, specifically, other compassion exercises are utilized when higher levels of certain narcissistic traits are present.
浮夸型自恋特质指的是剥削性和傲慢的态度,而脆弱型自恋特质则意味着对评判过度敏感且自尊心较低。对于具有自恋特质的个体如何改善他们对自己和他人的态度,人们知之甚少。当前的研究提出自我同情和他人同情是减轻某些自恋破坏模式的可能目标。一般来说,自我同情(SC)此前一直被认为对心理健康有有益影响,而他人同情(OC)则有利于人际关系。本研究探讨了自恋特质与实验性同情诱导效果之间的关系。学生和社区参与者(N = 230,M = 27.41,65.2%为女性)完成了浮夸型和脆弱型自恋特质、自我同情和他人同情状态问卷,以及自我同情或他人同情诱导。预计自恋特质较高(尤其是浮夸型特质)的个体将从诱导中受益,诱导后会表现出更高的自我同情,但在表现出有意义的他人同情增加(尤其是针对一般人群的他人同情)方面会有更大困难。结果表明,浮夸型和脆弱型自恋特质的个体差异与诱导后的改善程度有关:理论上对评判过度敏感的个体缺乏自我同情,似乎可以通过不同类型的同情练习来抵消。此外,较高的浮夸型剥削性 - 权利感和整体脆弱型自恋特质与比其他人更少的增加相关。然而,对具有这些特质的个体直接诱导他人同情与诱导自我同情后的改善相比,与更大的他人同情改善相关。总体而言,目前的研究结果表明,在过度敏感的个体中可以改善自我同情行为,并且如果在存在较高水平的某些自恋特质时专门使用他人同情练习,他人同情行为可能会潜在增加。