Shero Jeffrey A, Al Otaiba Stephanie, Schatschneider Chris, Hart Sara A
Florida State University.
Southern Methodist University.
J Exp Educ. 2022;90(4):1021-1040. doi: 10.1080/00220973.2021.1906198. Epub 2021 Apr 9.
Many of the analytical models commonly used in educational research often aim to maximize explained variance and identify variable importance within models. These models are useful for understanding general ideas and trends, but give limited insight into the individuals within said models. Data envelopment analysis (DEA), is a method rooted in organizational management that makes such insights possible. Unlike models alluded to above, DEA does not explain variance. Instead, it explains how efficiently an individual utilizes their inputs to produce outputs, and identifies which input is not being utilized optimally. This paper provides a history and usages of DEA from fields outside of education, and describes the math and processes behind it. This paper then extends DEA's usage into the educational field using a study on child reading ability. Using students from the Project KIDS dataset (), DEA is demonstrated using a simple view of reading framework, identifying individual efficiency levels in using reading-based skills to achieve reading comprehension, determining which skills are being underutilized, and classifying new subsets of readers. New subsets of readers were identified using this method, with implications for more targeted interventions.
教育研究中常用的许多分析模型通常旨在最大化解释方差,并确定模型中的变量重要性。这些模型有助于理解总体概念和趋势,但对模型中的个体洞察有限。数据包络分析(DEA)是一种源于组织管理的方法,它使这种洞察成为可能。与上述模型不同,DEA并不解释方差。相反,它解释个体如何有效地利用其输入来产生输出,并确定哪些输入未得到最优利用。本文介绍了DEA在教育领域之外的历史和用途,并描述了其背后的数学原理和过程。然后,本文通过一项关于儿童阅读能力的研究,将DEA的用途扩展到教育领域。使用来自“儿童项目”数据集的学生,通过阅读框架的简单视图展示了DEA,确定了使用基于阅读的技能实现阅读理解的个体效率水平,确定了哪些技能未得到充分利用,并对新的读者子集进行了分类。使用这种方法识别了新的读者子集,这对更有针对性的干预具有启示意义。