Center for Transplantation Sciences, Massachusetts General Hospital/Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
Ann Transplant. 2022 Nov 4;27:e937825. doi: 10.12659/AOT.937825.
BACKGROUND Weekends can impose resource and manpower constraints on hospitals. Studies using data from prior allocation schemas showed increased adult organ discards on weekends. We examined the impact of day of the week on adult and pediatric organ acceptance using contemporary data. MATERIAL AND METHODS Retrospective analysis of UNOS-PTR match-run data of all offers for potential kidney and liver transplant from 1/1/2016 to 7/1/2021 were examined to study the rate at which initial offers were declined depending on day of the week. Risk factors for decline were also evaluated. RESULTS Of the total initial adult/pediatric liver and kidney offers, the fewest offers occurred on Mondays and Sundays. The decline rate for adult/pediatric kidneys was highest on Saturdays and lowest on Tuesdays. The decline rate for adult livers was highest on Saturday and lowest on Wednesday. In contrast, the decline rate for pediatric livers was highest on Tuesdays and lowest on Wednesdays. Independent risk factors from multivariate analysis of the adult/pediatric kidney and liver decline rate were analyzed. The weekend offer remains an independent risk factor for adult kidney and liver offer declines, but for pediatric offers, these were not significant independent risk factors. CONCLUSIONS Although allocation systems have changed, and the availability of kidneys and livers have increased in the USA over the past 5 years, the weekend effect remains significant for adult liver and kidney offers for declines. Interestingly, the weekend effect was not seen for pediatric liver and kidney offers.
周末会给医院带来资源和人力方面的限制。先前的分配方案数据研究表明,周末成人器官的废弃率增加。我们使用当代数据研究了一周中不同天对成人和儿科器官接受的影响。
回顾性分析了 2016 年 1 月 1 日至 2021 年 7 月 1 日期间 UNOS-PTR 匹配运行数据中所有潜在肾脏和肝脏移植的供体数据,以研究初始供体根据供体时间被拒绝的比例。同时评估了下降的风险因素。
在总初始成人/儿科肝脏和肾脏供体中,周一和周日的供体数量最少。成人/儿科肾脏供体的下降率周六最高,周二最低。成人肝脏供体的下降率周六最高,周三最低。相比之下,儿科肝脏供体的下降率周二最高,周三最低。对成人/儿科肾脏和肝脏下降率的多变量分析进行了独立风险因素分析。周末供体仍然是成人肾脏和肝脏供体下降的独立危险因素,但对于儿科供体,这些并不是独立的显著危险因素。
尽管分配系统已经发生了变化,而且美国在过去 5 年中肾脏和肝脏的供应增加了,但周末效应仍然是成人肝脏和肾脏供体下降的一个重要因素。有趣的是,周末效应在儿科肝脏和肾脏供体中并未出现。