Department of Surgery, New York University Medical Center, New York, New York, USA.
Department of Surgery, University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, Cincinnati, Ohio, USA.
Clin Transplant. 2020 Sep;34(9):e13990. doi: 10.1111/ctr.13990. Epub 2020 Jul 4.
Changes to the United States kidney allocation system targeted at reducing organ discard have failed to improve organ utilization. High Kidney Donor Profile Index kidneys continue to be discarded at high rates as a result of the regulatory and financial barriers to widespread utilization of these organs. However, there are potential changes to clinical practice that could improve organ utilization. Expediting the time from initial offer to final organ acceptance would reduce cold ischemic time and should improve utilization. Implementation of procurement biopsy standards to avoid biopsy of low risk organs may prevent organ discards due to inaccurate data or excessive cold ischemia time. Further, standardization of procurement biopsy pathological interpretation coupled with electronic accessibility would enable early acceptance of difficult to transplant organs. These changes to allocation practice patterns are vital given proposals to expand the geographic sharing of deceased donor kidneys. Implementation of new allocation policies must be evaluated to ensure they result in higher transplant rates and acceptable post-transplant outcomes.
美国肾脏分配系统的改革旨在减少器官浪费,但未能提高器官利用率。由于广泛利用这些器官的监管和财务障碍,高肾脏捐赠者评分指数(Kidney Donor Profile Index,KDPI)的肾脏仍被大量丢弃。然而,临床实践中可能存在一些潜在的改变,可以提高器官利用率。加快从初始报价到最终器官接受的时间,将减少冷缺血时间,从而提高利用率。实施采购活检标准以避免对低风险器官进行活检,可能会防止因数据不准确或冷缺血时间过长而导致的器官丢弃。此外,采购活检病理解释的标准化以及电子获取,将使难以移植的器官能够尽早被接受。鉴于扩大已故供体肾脏的地理共享的提议,这些分配实践模式的改变至关重要。必须评估新分配政策的实施情况,以确保其带来更高的移植率和可接受的移植后结果。