Chiriboga Gonzalo, Peñaherrera Sophía, Londoño-Larrea Pablo, Castillo Luis, Carvajal C Ghem, Montero-Calderón Carolina
Universidad Central del Ecuador, Facultad de Ingeniería Química, Ritter S/N & Bolivia, Quito, Ecuador.
Universidad Central del Ecuador, Facultad de Ciencias, Jerónimo Leyton & Gatto Sobral, Quito, Ecuador.
Curr Res Food Sci. 2022 Oct 27;5:2022-2032. doi: 10.1016/j.crfs.2022.10.023. eCollection 2022.
The study aims to test if Ecuadorean coffee's symbolic and material contents agree with the instrumental analysis and grading protocols. We studied the relationship between the chemical composition and the organoleptic characteristics of eight non-specialty and six specialty coffee samples. Firstly, the study addresses the grading following the Specialty Coffee American Association (SCAA) method. The second stage focuses on the qualitative composition of the coffee brews employing GC-MS and caffeine concentrations using HPLC. Then, we employed statistical tools such as Cohen's concordance coefficients, dissimilarity dendrograms, and linear correlations between the chemical compounds in the beverage and the attributes' scores. The grading panel consisted of 6 semi-trained-testers who would assess if the primary cultural capital can provide a criterion to identify specialty coffee. The variety of compounds allowed the evaluators to distinguish between commercial and specialty coffees. However, the composition analysis identified molecules that would imply greater gradation in the tasting, a prevision that was not reflected in the results. Finally, we confirmed that basic training could create cultural capital to distinguish non-specialties from specialty coffees through their chemistry and organoleptic attributes.
该研究旨在测试厄瓜多尔咖啡的象征意义和物质成分是否符合仪器分析和分级标准。我们研究了八个非特色咖啡样本和六个特色咖啡样本的化学成分与感官特性之间的关系。首先,该研究采用特种咖啡协会(SCAA)的方法进行分级。第二阶段重点关注咖啡冲泡液的定性成分,采用气相色谱-质谱联用仪(GC-MS)分析,并使用高效液相色谱法(HPLC)测定咖啡因浓度。然后,我们运用了统计工具,如科恩一致性系数、差异树状图以及饮料中化合物与属性得分之间的线性相关性。分级小组由6名经过半培训的测试人员组成,他们将评估主要文化资本是否能够提供识别特色咖啡的标准。化合物的多样性使评估人员能够区分商业咖啡和特色咖啡。然而,成分分析确定了一些在品尝时可能意味着更高等级的分子,但这一预测并未在结果中得到体现。最后,我们证实基础培训可以通过咖啡的化学和感官属性创造文化资本,从而区分非特色咖啡和特色咖啡。