Musenyente Elijah, Han Marie L, Knigge Michel
Department of Community and Disability Studies, Faculty of Special Needs and Rehabilitation, Kyambogo University, Kampala, Uganda.
Department of Pedagogy, Faculty of Human Sciences, University of Potsdam, Potsdam, Germany.
Afr J Disabil. 2022 Oct 27;11:908. doi: 10.4102/ajod.v11i0.908. eCollection 2022.
The study was grounded in the recent developments of implementing the United Nations Convention on the Right of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD) in schools in Uganda, leading to a renewed interest in the questionings about inclusive education.
The inclusive approach was evaluated in terms of: (1) how public or private schools in Uganda understand inclusive education; (2) how schools implement inclusive education under the influence of the UN Convention; and (3) what determines the course of action and school routine of private and state schools.
This exploratory qualitative research included interviews with six schools purposively selected in Mukono, Wakiso and Kampala districts of Central Uganda. The selected schools comprised three private and three state schools (i.e. representing primary and secondary schools and a vocational training institute).
The research demonstrated that 'inclusive education practice' that was upheld by all the schools, was ironically stained with exclusion, for example, by non-admission of students with visual and hearing impairment, inaccessible physical environment, inadequate funding and separation of students according to abilities. However, whilst all schools followed the regular curriculum, some schools developed their own ways of teaching learners with diverse learning needs.
Some schools in Uganda have developed meaningful approaches of including students with disabilities but there are still many challenges for many. Enforcing Uganda's disability policies adapted from the CRPDs could enable learners with disabilities to enjoy their legal rights.
Since the intention of inclusion of students with disabilities stands in contrast to the reality of practice found in many schools, there seems to be a need to carry out regular assessments and measures of support for a sustainable inclusive school development.
该研究基于乌干达学校实施《联合国残疾人权利公约》(UNCRPD)的最新进展,引发了对全纳教育相关问题的新关注。
从以下方面评估全纳教育方法:(1)乌干达的公立或私立学校如何理解全纳教育;(2)学校在《联合国公约》影响下如何实施全纳教育;(3)是什么决定了私立和公立学校的行动方针和学校日常。
这项探索性定性研究包括对乌干达中部穆科诺、瓦基索和坎帕拉地区有目的地挑选的六所学校进行访谈。所选学校包括三所私立学校和三所公立学校(即代表小学、中学和一所职业培训机构)。
研究表明,所有学校所秉持的“全纳教育实践”,具有讽刺意味的是却存在排斥现象,例如不招收视力和听力受损的学生、物理环境不便、资金不足以及根据能力对学生进行区分。然而,虽然所有学校都遵循常规课程,但一些学校针对有不同学习需求的学习者开发了自己的教学方法。
乌干达的一些学校已经开发出了有意义的方法来接纳残疾学生,但对许多学校来说仍有诸多挑战。执行源自《残疾人权利公约》的乌干达残疾政策可以使残疾学习者享有其合法权利。
由于接纳残疾学生的意图与许多学校实际存在的情况形成反差,似乎有必要进行定期评估并采取支持措施,以实现可持续的全纳学校发展。