Meloni Marco, Ahluwalia Raju, Bellia Alfonso, Brocco Enrico, Di Venanzio Michela, Andreadi Aikaterini, Giurato Laura, Ruotolo Valeria, Di Daniele Nicola, Lauro Davide, Uccioli Luigi
Department of Systems Medicine, University of Rome "Tor Vergata", 00133 Rome, Italy.
Division of Endocrinology and Diabetology, Department of Medical Sciences, Fondazione Policlinico "Tor Vergata", 00133 Rome, Italy.
J Clin Med. 2022 Oct 22;11(21):6230. doi: 10.3390/jcm11216230.
The study aimed to evaluate the prevalence, characteristics and outcomes of patients affected by Charcot neuro-arthropathy (CN) and peripheral arterial disease (PAD) compared to CN without PAD. Consecutive patients presenting with an acute CN were included. The sample size was calculated by the power analysis by adopting the two-tailed tests of the null hypothesis with alfa = 0.05 and a value of beta = 0.10 as the second type error and, therefore, a test power equal to 90%. Seventy-six patients were identified. Twenty-four patients (31.6%) had neuro-ischaemic CN; they were older (66 vs. 57yrs), p = 0.03, had a longer diabetes duration (19 vs. 14yrs), p < 0.001, and more cases of end-stage-renal-disease (12.5 vs. 0%), p = 0.04 and ischaemic heart disease (58.3 vs. 15.4%), p < 0.0001 than neuropathic CN. Fifty patients (65.8%) had concomitant foot ulcers, 62.5% and 67.3% (p = 0.3), respectively, in CN with and without PAD. Neuro-ischaemic CN show arterial lesions of 2.9 vessels, and PAD was located predominantly below-the-knee (75%) but not below-the-ankle (16.7%). The outcomes for neuro-ischaemic and neuropathic CN patients were, respectively: wound healing (86.7 vs. 94.3%), p = 0.08; minor amputation (25 vs. 7.7%), p = 0.003; major amputation (8.3 vs. 1.9%), p = 0.001; hospitalization (75 vs. 23%), p = 0.0001. The study showed a frequent association between CN and PAD, leading to a neuro-ischaemic Charcot foot type. Neuro-ischaemic CN leaded to an increased risk of minor and major amputation and hospitalization, compared to neuropathic CN.
本研究旨在评估与无外周动脉疾病(PAD)的夏科特神经关节病(CN)相比,合并PAD的CN患者的患病率、特征及预后。纳入连续就诊的急性CN患者。样本量通过功效分析计算得出,采用双侧检验原假设,α = 0.05,β值 = 0.10作为第二类错误,检验效能为90%。共纳入76例患者。24例患者(31.6%)患有神经缺血性CN;他们年龄更大(66岁对57岁),p = 0.03,糖尿病病程更长(19年对14年),p < 0.001,终末期肾病病例更多(12.5%对0%),p = 0.04,缺血性心脏病病例更多(58.3%对15.4%),p < 0.0001,均高于神经性CN患者。50例患者(65.8%)伴有足部溃疡,合并PAD和未合并PAD的CN患者中分别为62.5%和67.3%(p = 0.3)。神经缺血性CN显示2.9支血管有动脉病变,PAD主要位于膝以下(75%),但踝以下少见(16.7%)。神经缺血性和神经性CN患者的预后分别为:伤口愈合(86.7%对94.3%),p = 0.08;小截肢(25%对7.7%),p = 0.003;大截肢(8.3%对1.9%),p = 0.001;住院(75%对23%),p = 0.0001。研究表明CN与PAD常相关,导致神经缺血性夏科特足类型。与神经性CN相比,神经缺血性CN导致小截肢、大截肢及住院风险增加。