Gil-Aucejo A, Martínez-Martín S, Flores-Sánchez P, Moyano-Hernández C, Sánchez-Morales P, Andrés-Martínez M, Calvo-Doñate E, Bataller-Guerrero M, García-García M A
Unidad de Cuidados Intensivos, Hospital de Sagunto, Valencia, Spain.
Universidad Católica de Valencia, Centro de Salud de Chirivella, Valencia, Spain.
Enferm Intensiva (Engl Ed). 2022 Oct-Dec;33(4):185-196. doi: 10.1016/j.enfie.2021.09.007. Epub 2022 Oct 31.
Current healthcare settings and ICUs especially are complex, highly technical, and multidisciplinary, with interactions between healthcare professionals and users, in which there may be errors at different levels. Our objective was to assess the perception of patient safety in our unit at the end of the third wave of the COVID pandemic, with the intention of conducting subsequent improvement actions.
Observational, cross-sectional, and descriptive study. The perception of Safety Culture was estimated using the HSOPS questionnaire translated into Spanish. Some questions were posed in a positive sense, and others in a negative sense. The response was also rated as positive, negative, or neutral. Our findings were compared visually, not mathematically, with those found in the previous national study «Analysis of the culture on patient safety in the hospital setting of the Spanish National Health System» published in 2009. A subgroup analysis was performed according to professional group and seniority as a health worker. The Student's t, χ and ANOVA tests were used.
Sixty-two professionals responded to the questionnaire, 73.90% of the total. The median time working in ICU 2 years (interquartile range 2-4.5 years). The rating for the degree of safety was 8.06 (SD 1.16). The majority (91.20%) had not reported any adverse event in the last year. A total of 30.90% had recently received patient safety training. The dimensions considered as weaknesses were 9 ("Staffing", with 27.57% of positive responses) and 10 ("Support of the hospital management in safety", with 17.64% of positive responses). The dimensions considered as strengths were 3 ("Expectation of actions by management/supervision of the service") with 85.29% of positive responses, and 5 ("Teamwork") with 95.58% of positive responses. The Cronbach's alpha index values suggest that the questionnaire has adequate internal consistency. In general, our data are more positive than those collected in the 2011 national survey, although the 2 dimensions considered weaknesses were already considered such in the previous work.
The perception of patient safety in the ICU of our hospital after the end of the third wave of the COVID pandemic is adequate, with a more positive rating than that of the national study on safety culture at the hospital level carried out in 2009. The constant quest for patient safety should prioritize activity in the 2 dimensions considered weaknesses: staffing, and support from hospital management in everything related to patient safety.
当前的医疗环境,尤其是重症监护病房,复杂、技术含量高且具有多学科性质,涉及医护人员与患者之间的互动,在这个过程中可能会出现不同层面的错误。我们的目标是在新冠疫情第三波结束时评估我们科室对患者安全的认知,以便后续开展改进措施。
观察性、横断面和描述性研究。使用翻译成西班牙语的HSOPS问卷来评估安全文化认知。一些问题以肯定的方式提出,另一些以否定的方式提出。回答也被评为积极、消极或中性。我们的研究结果与2009年发表的之前的全国性研究《西班牙国家卫生系统医院环境中患者安全文化分析》中的结果进行了直观比较,而非数学比较。根据专业组和作为医护人员的资历进行了亚组分析。使用了学生t检验、χ检验和方差分析。
62名专业人员回复了问卷,占总数的73.90%。在重症监护病房工作的中位时间为2年(四分位间距为2 - 4.5年)。安全程度评分是8.06(标准差为1.16)。大多数人(91.20%)在过去一年中未报告任何不良事件。共有30.90%的人最近接受了患者安全培训。被视为薄弱环节的维度是9(“人员配备”,积极回答占27.57%)和10(“医院管理层对安全的支持”,积极回答占17.64%)。被视为优势的维度是3(“对管理层行动的期望/服务监督”,积极回答占85.29%)和5(“团队合作”,积极回答占95.58%)。克朗巴哈α系数值表明问卷具有足够的内部一致性。总体而言,我们的数据比2011年全国调查收集的数据更积极,尽管被视为薄弱环节的2个维度在之前的研究中就已被认为是薄弱环节。
新冠疫情第三波结束后,我院重症监护病房对患者安全的认知是足够的,评分比2009年进行的关于医院层面安全文化的全国性研究更积极。对患者安全的持续追求应优先考虑在被视为薄弱环节的2个维度开展活动:人员配备以及医院管理层在与患者安全相关的所有方面的支持。