Förster Natalie, Forthmann Boris, Back Mitja D, Souvignier Elmar
Department of Psychology, University of Münster, Fliednerstraße 21, 48149 Münster, Germany.
Read Writ. 2023;36(2):289-315. doi: 10.1007/s11145-022-10379-y. Epub 2022 Nov 16.
In education, among the most anticipated consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic are that student performance will stagnate or decline and that existing inequities will increase. Although some studies suggest a decline in student performance and widening learning gaps, the picture is less clear than expected. In this study, we add to the existing literature on the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on student achievement. Specifically, we provide an analysis of the short- and mid-term effects of the pandemic on second grade reading performance in Germany using longitudinal assessments from over 19,500 students with eight measurement points in each school year. Interestingly, the effects of the pandemic established over time. Students in the first pandemic cohort even outperformed students from the pre-pandemic cohorts and showed a tendency towards decreased variances during the first lockdown. The second pandemic cohort showed no systematic mean differences, but generally had larger interindividual differences as compared to the pre-pandemic cohorts. While the gender achievement gap seemed unaffected by the pandemic, the gap between students with and without a migration background widened over time-though even before the pandemic. These results underline the importance of considering effects of the pandemic across cohorts, large samples, and fine-grained assessments. We discuss our findings considering the context-specific educational challenges and in terms of practical implications for teachers' professional development.
在教育领域,新冠疫情最令人担忧的后果之一是学生成绩将停滞不前或下降,以及现有的不平等现象会加剧。尽管一些研究表明学生成绩有所下降,学习差距不断扩大,但实际情况比预期的要模糊。在本研究中,我们补充了关于新冠疫情对学生成绩影响的现有文献。具体而言,我们利用德国19500多名学生在每个学年的八个测量点进行的纵向评估,分析了疫情对二年级阅读成绩的短期和中期影响。有趣的是,疫情的影响随时间推移而显现。疫情第一年的学生甚至比疫情前的学生表现更好,并且在第一次封锁期间方差有减小的趋势。疫情第二年的学生没有表现出系统性的平均差异,但与疫情前的学生相比,个体间差异普遍更大。虽然性别成绩差距似乎未受疫情影响,但有和没有移民背景的学生之间的差距随着时间推移而扩大——尽管在疫情之前就已存在。这些结果凸显了在不同群体、大样本和精细评估中考虑疫情影响的重要性。我们结合具体的教育挑战背景以及对教师专业发展的实际影响来讨论我们的研究结果。