de Laat Kim
Kim de Laat is a Postdoctoral Fellow at Brock University.
Ind Labor Relat Rev. 2023 Jan;76(1):135-159. doi: 10.1177/00197939221076134. Epub 2022 Feb 14.
In-depth interviews with IT employees ( = 84) working under two types of work design-a post-bureaucratic work design labeled "agile," and a bureaucratic work design labeled "waterfall"-are used to examine gendered patterns in the adoption of remote work. Interviews reveal an unintended consequence of the agile model: It promotes a physical orientation that induces on-site work. Agile is gender-inegalitarian, with more women than men working remotely despite its perceived unacceptability, and low numbers of employees working remotely overall. By contrast, workers within a waterfall work design express a digital orientation to work and feel empowered to work remotely. The waterfall model is associated with gender egalitarianism; most employees opt to work remotely, and men and women do so in even numbers. Findings suggest that when compared to the post-bureaucratic work design, the bureaucratic work design provides more flexibility. This article refines our understanding of barriers to remote work and provides a lens on the gender dynamics underlying work design.
对在两种工作设计模式下工作的84名信息技术员工进行了深入访谈,这两种工作设计模式分别是被称为“敏捷”的后官僚主义工作设计和被称为“瀑布式”的官僚主义工作设计,旨在研究远程工作采用过程中的性别模式。访谈揭示了敏捷模式一个意想不到的后果:它促进了一种导致现场工作的实体导向。敏捷模式存在性别不平等,尽管它被认为不可接受,但远程工作的女性比男性多,而且总体上远程工作的员工数量较少。相比之下,瀑布式工作设计模式下的员工表现出对工作的数字导向,并感到有能力远程工作。瀑布式模式与性别平等主义相关;大多数员工选择远程工作,男性和女性的人数相当。研究结果表明,与后官僚主义工作设计相比,官僚主义工作设计提供了更大的灵活性。本文完善了我们对远程工作障碍的理解,并为工作设计背后的性别动态提供了一个视角。