Department of Sport, Health and Exercise Science, University of Hull, Hull,United Kingdom.
Newcastle University Centre for Cancer, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne,United Kingdom.
Int J Sports Physiol Perform. 2022 Dec 2;18(3):231-239. doi: 10.1123/ijspp.2021-0570. Print 2023 Mar 1.
To compare the effects of variable-resistance complex training (VRCT) versus traditional complex training (TCT) on muscle architecture in rugby league players during a 6-week mesocycle.
Twenty-four rugby league players competing in the British University & Colleges Sport (BUCS) Premier North Division were randomized to VRCT (n = 8), TCT (n = 8), or control (n = 8). Experimental groups completed a 6-week lower-body complex training intervention (2×/wk), which involved alternating high-load resistance exercise with plyometric exercise in the same session. The VRCT group performed resistance exercises at 70% of 1-repetition maximum (1RM) + 0% to 23% of 1RM from band resistance with a 90-second intracontrast rest interval, whereas the TCT group performed resistance exercise at 93% of 1RM with a 4-minute intracontrast rest interval. Muscle thickness (MT), pennation angle, and fascicle length (Lf) were assessed for the vastus lateralis (VL) and gastrocnemius medialis using ultrasound imaging.
Both TCT and VRCT groups significantly improved VL MT and VL Lf compared with control (all P < .05). Standardized within-group changes in MT and Lf (Cohen dav ± 95% CI) were moderate for TCT (dav = 0.91 ± 1.0; dav = 1.1 ± 1.1) and unclear for VRCT (dav = 0.44 ± 0.99; dav = 0.47 ± 0.99), respectively. Differences in change scores between TCT and VRCT were unclear.
VRCT and TCT can be utilized during the competitive season to induce favorable MT and Lf muscle architecture adaptations for the VL. TCT may induce greater muscle architecture adaptations of the VL, whereas VRCT may be of more practical value given the shorter intracontrast rest interval between resistance and plyometric exercises.
比较变阻力复合训练(VRCT)与传统复合训练(TCT)对英式橄榄球运动员在 6 周中周期内肌肉结构的影响。
24 名参加英国大学和学院运动(BUCS)英超北区的英式橄榄球运动员被随机分为 VRCT 组(n=8)、TCT 组(n=8)或对照组(n=8)。实验组完成了为期 6 周的下肢复合训练干预(每周 2 次),该干预包括在同一次训练中交替进行高负荷阻力训练和增强式训练。VRCT 组在 90 秒的内对比休息间隔内以 70%的 1 次重复最大重量(1RM)+0%至 23%的 1RM 进行阻力训练,而 TCT 组在 4 分钟的内对比休息间隔内以 93%的 1RM 进行阻力训练。使用超声成像评估股外侧肌(VL)和比目鱼肌内侧的肌肉厚度(MT)、肌纤维角度和肌束长度(Lf)。
与对照组相比,TCT 和 VRCT 组的 VL MT 和 VL Lf 均显著改善(均 P <.05)。TCT 的 MT 和 Lf 的组内变化标准化值(Cohen dav ± 95%CI)为中等(dav = 0.91 ± 1.0;dav = 1.1 ± 1.1),而 VRCT 的组内变化标准化值(Cohen dav ± 95%CI)为不清楚(dav = 0.44 ± 0.99;dav = 0.47 ± 0.99)。TCT 和 VRCT 之间的变化评分差异不明显。
VRCT 和 TCT 可在比赛季节用于诱导 VL 肌肉结构的有利变化。TCT 可能会引起 VL 更大的肌肉结构适应性变化,而 VRCT 由于在阻力训练和增强式训练之间的内对比休息间隔较短,可能具有更大的实用价值。