Deshayes Maxime, Palermo Angèle, Korchi Karim, Philippe Antony G
UNIV. NIMES, APSY-V, F-30021 Nîmes Cedex 1, France.
Front Sports Act Living. 2022 Nov 25;4:998724. doi: 10.3389/fspor.2022.998724. eCollection 2022.
The present research examined the effect of a negative stereotype induction on older adults' physical activity level, measured objectively and subjectively. Twenty older adults (18 women and two men; age = 67.4, age = 4.4) were assigned to a control condition, a neutral condition and a negative stereotype condition during three separate visits (i.e., within-subject design). In each physical activity session, participants performed the same training. Objective physical activity level was the time spent at moderate to vigorous intensity measured by accelerometry and subjective physical activity level was measured with the RPE-session method. Inactivity time was also objectively assessed. Results revealed no effect of the different conditions on objective physical activity level, but subjective physical activity level and inactivity time were lower in the neutral condition and in the negative stereotype condition compared to the control condition. It was suggested that when a negative stereotype is induced, participants perceived the task as less intense compared to the control condition, which result in less inactivity time, suggesting that the negative stereotype had a positive influence on physical activity. Another interesting result was that effects were similar in the negative stereotype condition and in the neutral condition, revealing that the neutral condition might not be a control condition. While these results are not in line with the stereotype threat literature, they echo previous recent studies also showing a positive effect of a negative stereotype induction, calling into question the stereotype threat theory.
本研究考察了负面刻板印象诱导对老年人身体活动水平的影响,包括客观测量和主观测量。20名老年人(18名女性和2名男性;年龄=67.4,标准差=4.4)在三次单独的访视中(即被试内设计)被分配到控制组、中性组和负面刻板印象组。在每次身体活动环节中,参与者进行相同的训练。客观身体活动水平是通过加速度计测量的中度至剧烈强度的运动时间,主观身体活动水平则采用RPE-环节法进行测量。不活动时间也进行了客观评估。结果显示,不同条件对客观身体活动水平没有影响,但与控制组相比,中性组和负面刻板印象组的主观身体活动水平和不活动时间较低。研究表明,当诱导出负面刻板印象时,与控制组相比,参与者认为任务强度较小,这导致不活动时间减少,表明负面刻板印象对身体活动有积极影响。另一个有趣的结果是,负面刻板印象组和中性组的效果相似,这表明中性组可能不是一个控制组。虽然这些结果与刻板印象威胁文献不一致,但它们与最近的其他研究结果相呼应,这些研究也表明负面刻板印象诱导有积极影响,这对刻板印象威胁理论提出了质疑。