Lan Yihong, Yin Li, Wang Xiaoqin
Suntar Research Institute, Singapore, Singapore.
Karolinska Institutet, Solna, Sweden.
Emerg Themes Epidemiol. 2022 Dec 22;19(1):10. doi: 10.1186/s12982-022-00119-6.
The pandemic progression is a dynamic process, in which measures yield outcomes, and outcomes in turn influence subsequent measures and outcomes. Due to the dynamics of pandemic progression, it is challenging to analyse the long-term influence of an individual measure in the sequence on pandemic outcomes. To demonstrate the problem and find solutions, in this article, we study the first wave of the pandemic-probably the most dynamic period-in the Nordic countries and analyse the influences of the Swedish measures relative to the measures adopted by its neighbouring countries on COVID-19 mortality, general mortality, COVID-19 incidence, and unemployment. The design is a longitudinal observational study. The linear regressions based on the Poisson distribution or the binomial distribution are employed for the analysis. To show that analysis can be timely conducted, we use table data available during the first wave. We found that the early Swedish measure had a long-term and significant causal effect on public health outcomes and a certain degree of long-term mitigating causal effect on unemployment during the first wave, where the effect was measured by an increase of these outcomes under the Swedish measures relative to the measures adopted by the other Nordic countries. This information from the first wave has not been provided by available analyses but could have played an important role in combating the second wave. In conclusion, analysis based on table data may provide timely information about the dynamic progression of a pandemic and the long-term influence of an individual measure in the sequence on pandemic outcomes.
疫情发展是一个动态过程,在此过程中,措施产生结果,而结果反过来又会影响后续措施及结果。由于疫情发展的动态性,分析序列中某项措施对疫情结果的长期影响具有挑战性。为了说明这一问题并找到解决方案,在本文中,我们研究了北欧国家疫情的第一波——可能是最具动态性的时期——并分析了瑞典采取的措施相对于其邻国所采取的措施对新冠死亡率、总体死亡率、新冠发病率和失业率的影响。该设计为纵向观察性研究。分析采用基于泊松分布或二项分布的线性回归。为了表明分析可以及时进行,我们使用了第一波疫情期间可用的表格数据。我们发现,瑞典早期采取的措施对公共卫生结果具有长期且显著的因果效应,并且在第一波疫情期间对失业率具有一定程度的长期缓解因果效应,这种效应通过瑞典措施下这些结果相对于其他北欧国家所采取措施的增加来衡量。第一波疫情的这些信息尚未在现有分析中给出,但可能在抗击第二波疫情中发挥了重要作用。总之,基于表格数据的分析可能会及时提供有关疫情动态发展以及序列中某项措施对疫情结果的长期影响的信息。