Ranzato Giovanna, Adriaens Ines, Lora Isabella, Aernouts Ben, Statham Jonathan, Azzolina Danila, Meuwissen Dyan, Prosepe Ilaria, Zidi Ali, Cozzi Giulio
Department of Animal Medicine, Production and Health (MAPS), University of Padova, Viale dell'Università 16, 35020 Legnaro, Italy.
Division of Animal and Human Health Engineering, Department of Biosystems, KU Leuven, Campus Geel, Kleinhoefstraat 4, 2440 Geel, Belgium.
Animals (Basel). 2022 Dec 10;12(24):3494. doi: 10.3390/ani12243494.
Early predictions of cows' probability of survival to different lactations would help farmers in making successful management and breeding decisions. For this purpose, this research explored the adoption of joint models for longitudinal and survival data in the dairy field. An algorithm jointly modelled daily first-lactation sensor data (milk yield, body weight, rumination time) and survival data (i.e., time to culling) from 6 Holstein dairy farms. The algorithm was set to predict survival to the beginning of the second and third lactations (i.e., second and third calving) from sensor observations of the first 60, 150, and 240 days in milk of cows' first lactation. Using 3-time-repeated 3-fold cross-validation, the performance was evaluated in terms of Area Under the Curve and expected error of prediction. Across the different scenarios and farms, the former varied between 45% and 76%, while the latter was between 3.5% and 26%. Significant results were obtained in terms of expected error of prediction, meaning that the method provided survival probabilities in line with the observed events in the datasets (i.e., culling). Furthermore, the performances were stable among farms. These features may justify further research on the use of joint models to predict the survival of dairy cattle.
早期预测奶牛存活至不同泌乳期的概率,将有助于奶农做出成功的管理和育种决策。为此,本研究探索了在奶牛养殖领域采用纵向数据和生存数据的联合模型。一种算法对来自6个荷斯坦奶牛场的每日首次泌乳期传感器数据(产奶量、体重、反刍时间)和生存数据(即淘汰时间)进行联合建模。该算法设定为根据奶牛首次泌乳期前60天、150天和240天的传感器观测数据,预测存活至第二次和第三次泌乳期开始(即第二次和第三次产犊)的概率。使用3次重复的3折交叉验证,根据曲线下面积和预期预测误差对性能进行评估。在不同场景和农场中,前者在45%至76%之间变化,而后者在3.5%至26%之间。在预期预测误差方面获得了显著结果,这意味着该方法提供的生存概率与数据集中观察到的事件(即淘汰)相符。此外,各农场之间的性能较为稳定。这些特点可能为进一步研究使用联合模型预测奶牛的生存情况提供依据。