Hameeteman W, v d Boomgaard D M, Dekker W, Schrijver M, Wesdorp I C, Tytgat G N
Department of Gastro-enterology, Academic Medical Centre, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
J Clin Gastroenterol. 1987 Aug;9(4):390-4. doi: 10.1097/00004836-198708000-00007.
A single-blind randomized multicenter study was performed in 42 patients with endoscopically documented reflux esophagitis. Patients were randomly given 400 mg cimetidine q.i.d. or a suspension of 1 g sucralfate q.i.d. for a period of 8 weeks. Forty patients were evaluated after 8 weeks. Symptomatic improvement was good and was comparable in both groups. We saw side-effects in only three patients, two on sucralfate and one on cimetidine, and these did not necessitate withdrawal from the study. Endoscopy showed improvement of esophagitis in 53% and healing in 31% of patients after sucralfate treatment. With cimetidine, improvement was seen in 67% and healing in 14%. One patient on cimetidine developed a stricture during treatment. We conclude that treatment with sucralfate improves symptoms and lessens severity of reflux esophagitis and that the results with sucralfate appear to be comparable to those obtained with cimetidine. Sucralfate is a valid alternative to H2-receptor antagonist therapy.
对42例经内镜证实患有反流性食管炎的患者进行了一项单盲随机多中心研究。患者被随机给予西咪替丁400毫克每日4次或硫糖铝混悬液1克每日4次,为期8周。8周后对40例患者进行了评估。两组的症状改善情况均良好且相当。我们仅在3例患者中观察到副作用,2例使用硫糖铝,1例使用西咪替丁,且这些副作用并未导致患者退出研究。内镜检查显示,硫糖铝治疗后,53%的患者食管炎有所改善,31%的患者愈合。使用西咪替丁时,改善率为67%,愈合率为14%。1例使用西咪替丁的患者在治疗期间出现了狭窄。我们得出结论,硫糖铝治疗可改善症状并减轻反流性食管炎的严重程度,且硫糖铝的治疗效果似乎与西咪替丁相当。硫糖铝是H2受体拮抗剂治疗的有效替代药物。