Overbeek Remco, Schmitz Jan, Rehnberg Lucas, Benyoucef Yacine, Dusse Fabian, Russomano Thais, Hinkelbein Jochen
Department of Anesthesiology and Intensive Care Medicine, Faculty of Medicine and University Hospital Cologne, University of Cologne, 50937 Cologne, Germany.
German Society of Aerospace Medicine (DGLRM), 80331 Munich, Germany.
Life (Basel). 2022 Nov 23;12(12):1958. doi: 10.3390/life12121958.
(1) Background: Cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), as a form of basic life support, is critical for maintaining cardiac and cerebral perfusion during cardiac arrest, a medical condition with high expected mortality. Current guidelines emphasize the importance of rapid recognition and prompt initiation of high-quality CPR, including appropriate cardiac compression depth and rate. As space agencies plan missions to the Moon or even to explore Mars, the duration of missions will increase and with it the chance of life-threatening conditions requiring CPR. The objective of this review was to examine the effectiveness and feasibility of chest compressions as part of CPR following current terrestrial guidelines under hypogravity conditions such as those encountered on planetary or lunar surfaces; (2) Methods: A systematic literature search was conducted by two independent reviewers (PubMed, Cochrane Register of Controlled Trials, ResearchGate, National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)). Only controlled trials conducting CPR following guidelines from 2010 and after with advised compression depths of 50 mm and above were included; (3) Results: Four different publications were identified. All studies examined CPR feasibility in 0.38 G simulating the gravitational force on Mars. Two studies also simulated hypogravity on the Moon with a force of 0.17 G/0,16 G. All CPR protocols consisted of chest compressions only without ventilation. A compression rate above 100/s could be maintained in all studies and hypogravity conditions. Two studies showed a significant reduction of compression depth in 0.38 G (-7.2 mm/-8.71 mm) and 0.17 G (-12.6 mm/-9.85 mm), respectively, with nearly similar heart rates, compared to 1 G conditions. In the other two studies, participants with higher body weight could maintain a nearly adequate mean depth while effort measured by heart rate (+23/+13.85 bpm) and VO (+5.4 mL·kg·min) increased significantly; (4) Conclusions: Adequate CPR quality in hypogravity can only be achieved under increased physical stress to compensate for functional weight loss. Without this extra effort, the depth of compression quickly falls below the guideline level, especially for light-weight rescuers. This means faster fatigue during resuscitation and the need for more frequent changes of the resuscitator than advised in terrestrial guidelines. Alternative techniques in the straddling position should be further investigated in hypogravity.
(1)背景:心肺复苏术(CPR)作为基本生命支持的一种形式,对于在心脏骤停(一种预期死亡率很高的病症)期间维持心脏和大脑灌注至关重要。当前指南强调快速识别和及时启动高质量心肺复苏术的重要性,包括适当的心脏按压深度和速率。随着太空机构计划执行前往月球甚至探索火星的任务,任务持续时间将会增加,随之出现需要心肺复苏术的危及生命状况的可能性也会增加。本综述的目的是研究在诸如行星或月球表面所遇到的低重力条件下,按照当前地面指南进行的心肺复苏术中胸外按压的有效性和可行性;(2)方法:由两名独立评审员(通过PubMed、Cochrane对照试验注册库、ResearchGate、美国国家航空航天局(NASA))进行系统的文献检索。仅纳入按照2010年及以后的指南进行心肺复苏术且建议按压深度为50毫米及以上的对照试验;(3)结果:共识别出四份不同的出版物。所有研究均在模拟火星重力的0.38G条件下检验了心肺复苏术的可行性。两项研究还在0.17G/0.16G的重力条件下模拟了月球低重力环境。所有心肺复苏方案均仅包括胸外按压,不进行通气。在所有研究和低重力条件下均能维持高于100次/秒的按压速率。两项研究表明,与1G条件相比,在0.38G(-7.2毫米/-8.71毫米)和0.17G(-12.6毫米/-9.85毫米)条件下按压深度分别显著降低,心率几乎相似。在另外两项研究中,体重较大的参与者能够维持接近足够的平均深度,但通过心率(+23/+13.85次/分钟)和摄氧量(+5.4毫升·千克·分钟)衡量的用力程度显著增加;(4)结论:在低重力环境下,只有在增加身体压力以补偿功能失重的情况下,才能实现足够的心肺复苏质量。如果没有这种额外的努力,按压深度会迅速降至指南水平以下,尤其是对于体重较轻的施救者。在低重力环境下,应进一步研究跨坐姿势的替代技术。