Tsai Ming-Jong, Wu Lung-Fa
Graduate Institute of Automation and Control, National Taiwan University of Science and Technology, Taipei 106335, Taiwan.
Materials (Basel). 2022 Dec 16;15(24):8998. doi: 10.3390/ma15248998.
This study proposed an effective method for optimizing laser drilling processing (LDP) by using grey relational analysis (GRA) for multiple performance requirements. First, we developed a system using a Quantel Brilliant Neodymium-doped Yttrium Aluminum Garnet (Nd: YAG) laser with a pulse width of 5-6 ns and F-theta lenses to deliver a focused laser beam with a diameter of 0.2 mm. The developed system was first employed to drill holes in a 3-mm-thick optical-grade acrylic polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) plate on a safe window with a high optical density and a grade of OD 7+ @ 950~1085 nm. To avoid errors in the experimental data due to unstable power, a laser power (energy) meter was used to measure the energy stability of the Quantel Brilliant Pulse Laser. Given the stability of 5.6%, this is an effective method for LDP. Four control factors were investigated, including laser pulse energy, repetition rate, focusing position offset, and drilling time. Then, nine experiments were performed using the Taguchi method with orthogonal arrays in L (3). The experimental results with multiple quality characteristics were measured and used to optimize the control factors by using GRA with equal weighting of the four qualities (roundness, Hillock ratio, taper, and HAZ). The results show that A1B3C1D1 is the optimal combination of the control factors, and the maximal variation of 0.406 is obtained from the control factor B (focusing position offset) which has the greatest contribution to the drilling time. We then performed confirmation experiment and obtained a better result from the combination of the control factors, A1B3C1D1. GRA helps us determine the best laser drilling parameters to meet the desired multiple drilling qualities.
本研究提出了一种通过灰色关联分析(GRA)优化激光钻孔加工(LDP)以满足多种性能要求的有效方法。首先,我们开发了一个系统,该系统使用脉宽为5 - 6 ns的Quantel Brilliant掺钕钇铝石榴石(Nd:YAG)激光器和F - theta透镜来输出直径为0.2 mm的聚焦激光束。所开发的系统首先用于在一块3毫米厚的光学级丙烯酸聚甲基丙烯酸甲酯(PMMA)板上的安全窗口处钻孔,该安全窗口具有高光学密度且在950~1085 nm波长下的OD等级为7 +。为避免因功率不稳定导致实验数据出现误差,使用激光功率(能量)计来测量Quantel Brilliant脉冲激光器的能量稳定性。鉴于其5.6%的稳定性,这是一种有效的激光钻孔加工方法。研究了四个控制因素,包括激光脉冲能量、重复频率、聚焦位置偏移和钻孔时间。然后,采用田口方法在L(3)正交阵列下进行了九次实验。测量了具有多个质量特性的实验结果,并通过对四个质量(圆度、小丘比率、锥度和热影响区)进行等权重的灰色关联分析来优化控制因素。结果表明,A1B3C1D1是控制因素的最优组合,并且控制因素B(聚焦位置偏移)对钻孔时间贡献最大,其最大变化量为0.406。然后我们进行了验证实验,并从控制因素组合A1B3C1D1中获得了更好的结果。灰色关联分析有助于我们确定最佳的激光钻孔参数,以满足所需的多种钻孔质量要求。