Villani Cecilia, Piccioni Rolando
Veterinary Service of Food Hygiene of Animal Origin, Department of Prevention, ASL 4 Teramo, Italy.
Ital J Food Saf. 2022 Dec 12;11(4):10761. doi: 10.4081/ijfs.2022.10761. eCollection 2022 Dec 5.
Slaughtered animals are regularly submitted to inspection to ensure that all the edible parts are fit for human consumption. According to Regulation (EU) No 219/2014, pig carcasses inspection is exclusively visual as palpation and incision could lead to cross-contamination and spread of relevant zoonotic agents. However, when compared to incision and palpation, the visual method is characterized by low sensitivity; thus, the omission of incision and palpation could lead to a reduced detection capability of organic lesions. This study aims to assess the effectiveness of exclusively visual inspection to mark pulmonary and hepatic lesions associated with low public health impact diseases in pork carcasses. A quasiexperimental- before/after research protocol has been used. All the inspections have been carried out in a slaughterhouse located in the province of Teramo (IT), on 7,764 swine from 2011 to 2017. Carcasses undergone the only visual inspection have shown a statistically significant reduction (pvalue <0.0001) in the diagnosis of hepatic (decrease of 59%) and pulmonary diseases (decrease of 38. 5%). To overcome the limits of the low sensitivity of the visual inspection, as well as the inter-operator diagnostic variability, the high number of carcasses examined is proposed as a factor conferring external validity to the study, which provides quantitative evidence in support of the causal association between the modified inspection technique and the reduced diagnostic capacity. A further support derives from the assessment of the prevalence of hepatic and pulmonary diseases in species for whom the inspection technique is not changed.
屠宰动物需定期接受检查,以确保所有可食用部分适合人类食用。根据欧盟第219/2014号法规,猪胴体检查仅采用目视检查,因为触诊和切口可能导致交叉污染和相关人畜共患病原体的传播。然而,与切口和触诊相比,目视检查方法的特点是灵敏度低;因此,省略切口和触诊可能会导致器质性病变的检测能力下降。本研究旨在评估仅通过目视检查来标记猪肉胴体中与低公共卫生影响疾病相关的肺部和肝脏病变的有效性。采用了一种准实验性的前后研究方案。所有检查均在位于意大利泰拉莫省的一家屠宰场进行',对2011年至2017年的7764头猪进行了检查。仅接受目视检查的胴体在肝脏疾病(减少59%)和肺部疾病(减少38.5%)的诊断方面显示出统计学上的显著下降(p值<0.0001)。为了克服目视检查灵敏度低的局限性以及操作人员之间的诊断变异性,建议将大量检查的胴体数量作为赋予该研究外部有效性的一个因素,该研究提供了定量证据来支持改良检查技术与诊断能力下降之间的因果关系。进一步的支持来自于对检查技术未改变的物种中肝脏和肺部疾病患病率的评估。