Marcks Katharine L, Zhao Yihong, Motro Melih, Will Leslie A
Department of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, Boston University Henry M. Goldman School of Dental Medicine, Boston, MA, USA.
Turk J Orthod. 2022 Dec;35(4):239-247. doi: 10.5152/TurkJOrthod.2022.21237.
To determine whether multiple siblings resemble one another in their craniofacial characteristics as measured on cephalometric radiographs.
This study was conducted retrospectively using the Forsyth Moorrees twin sample. A total of 32 families were included, each with ≥4 postpubertal siblings, totaling 142 subjects. Only 1 monozygotic twin was included per family. Headfilms were digitized, skeletal landmarks were located, and 6 parameters that indicated sagittal jaw relationships and vertical status were measured. Diverse statistical approaches were used. Dixon's Q-test detected outliers in a family for a given parameter. Manhattan Distance quantified similarity among siblings per parameter. Scatter plots visually displayed subject's measure relative to the mean and standard deviation of each parameter to assess the clinical relevance of the differences.
A total of 11 families (34.4%) had no outliers on any parameter, 13 families (40.6%) had outliers on 1 parameter, and 8 families (25%) had outliers on ≥2 parameters. We identified 29 individuals with at least 1 outlying measure (20.4%). Among these, only 2 individuals (1.4%) were significantly different from their siblings for more than 1 measurement. Although the majority of the families did not demonstrate any statistical outlier, the ranges of the measurements were clinically relevant as they might suggest different treatment. For example, the mean range of SNB (Sella-Nasion-B point) angles was 7.23°, and the mean range of MPA was 9.42°.
Although families are generally not dissimilar in their craniofacial characteristics, measurements from siblings cannot be used to predict the measurements of another sibling in a clinically meaningful way.
通过头影测量X线片来确定多个兄弟姐妹在颅面特征上是否彼此相似。
本研究采用Forsyth Moorrees双生子样本进行回顾性研究。共纳入32个家庭,每个家庭有≥4个青春期后兄弟姐妹,共计142名受试者。每个家庭仅纳入1对同卵双胞胎。对头影测量片进行数字化处理,确定骨骼标志点,并测量6个表明矢状颌关系和垂直状态的参数。使用了多种统计方法。Dixon Q检验检测给定参数在一个家庭中的异常值。曼哈顿距离量化每个参数下兄弟姐妹之间的相似性。散点图直观地展示了受试者相对于每个参数的均值和标准差的测量值,以评估差异的临床相关性。
共有11个家庭(34.4%)在任何参数上均无异常值,13个家庭(40.6%)在1个参数上有异常值,8个家庭(25%)在≥2个参数上有异常值。我们识别出29名至少有1项异常测量值的个体(20.4%)。其中,只有2名个体(1.4%)在超过1项测量中与其兄弟姐妹有显著差异。尽管大多数家庭未显示任何统计学上的异常值,但测量范围具有临床相关性,因为它们可能提示不同的治疗方法。例如,SNB(蝶鞍-鼻根点-B点)角的平均范围为7.23°,MPA的平均范围为9.42°。
尽管一般来说家庭在颅面特征上没有差异,但兄弟姐妹的测量值不能以具有临床意义的方式用于预测另一个兄弟姐妹的测量值。