School of Life Sciences, University of Liverpool, UK.
FEBS Open Bio. 2023 Feb;13(2):217-232. doi: 10.1002/2211-5463.13548. Epub 2023 Jan 16.
Lecture capture (the real-time recording of live lectures) has become commonplace in higher education. It is popular with students who like the associated flexibility and believe that lecture recordings improve their grades. Here, we performed a survey (n = 694, 53% of the cohort) and set up focus groups (2 focus groups, 15 participants) to explore biological sciences students' perceptions of how lecture capture impacts their study behaviour when recordings are provided for every lecture and are made available to students without restriction. The participants in our study were convinced that lecture capture improved their learning, and many students noted that they were dependent on the recordings, thinking that without them, they would not be able to achieve good grades. Students reported that they spend a considerable amount of time watching recordings and making verbatim notes, leaving them little time for independent study. For many, lecture capture seems to reinforce the view that memorisation equals learning, a view that may be reinforced by knowledge-focussed assessment formats. For most students, lecture capture did not affect self-reported live lecture attendance patterns. However, about one-third of the participants reported skipping more classes, and the same participants were more likely to postpone catching up on missed lectures. The outcomes of our study suggest that lecture capture provision may negatively affect some students' attendance and study behaviour, and thus, we suggest more needs to be done to mitigate against this.
课堂录制(实时录制现场讲座)在高等教育中已变得很普遍。它受到喜欢这种灵活性的学生的欢迎,并且他们认为讲座录音可以提高他们的成绩。在这里,我们进行了一项调查(n=694,占学生总数的 53%)并设立了焦点小组(2 个焦点小组,每组 15 名参与者),以探讨生物科学专业学生对讲座录制的看法,即在提供所有讲座的录音且不对学生进行任何限制的情况下,这会如何影响他们的学习行为。我们研究中的参与者坚信,课堂录制提高了他们的学习效果,许多学生指出,他们依赖于录音,认为如果没有这些录音,他们就无法取得好成绩。学生们报告说,他们花费了大量的时间观看录音并做逐字记录,这使得他们几乎没有时间进行独立学习。对许多人来说,课堂录制似乎强化了死记硬背等于学习的观点,而这种观点可能会受到以知识为重点的评估方式的强化。对于大多数学生来说,课堂录制并没有影响他们报告的现场讲座出勤率模式。然而,大约三分之一的参与者报告说他们跳过了更多的课程,而这些参与者更有可能推迟弥补错过的课程。我们研究的结果表明,课堂录制的提供可能会对一些学生的出勤率和学习行为产生负面影响,因此,我们建议需要采取更多措施来减轻这种影响。