Beaton Laura, Knights Jennifer, Barnsley Lorna, Araujo Mariana, Clarkson Jan, Freeman Ruth, Young Linda, Yuan Siyang, Humphris Gerry
NHS Education for Scotland, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
School of Dentistry, University of Dundee, Dundee, United Kingdom.
Front Oral Health. 2022 Dec 22;3:1074655. doi: 10.3389/froh.2022.1074655. eCollection 2022.
The COVID-19 pandemic resulted in a series of significant changes and adjustments within dentistry, as dental professionals dealt with temporary closures of dental practices, increased use of personal protective equipment, a reduction of clinical procedures, and extensions to training programmes. Recent research has illustrated the impact of the pandemic on the dental profession, indicating that many dental professionals felt emotionally exhausted and experienced significant uncertainty and anxiety. This qualitative study aimed to understand how these experiences and emotions changed over the course of six months, in dental trainees and primary dental care staff in Scotland.
A longitudinal diary study was conducted (June-December 2020) with dental trainees and primary dental care staff. The diary asked respondents to answer three questions related to their emotional exhaustion, on a weekly basis. There was also an open question asking respondents to describe any significant issues or concerns they had experienced during the preceding week because of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on their work or training. This qualitative data was explored using a trajectory analysis approach to determine specifically changes over time.
The trajectory analysis revealed several key concerns prevalent amongst respondents, and how they fluctuated over the six months. Concerns included: the impact of the pandemic on respondents' future careers and on dentistry more generally; adapting to new working environments; the impact on their patients' dental treatment and oral health; the impact on their health and wellbeing; financial considerations and adjusting to new safety measures as part of the remobilization of dental services.
In the second half of 2020, as the UK was adjusting to the introduction of new COVID-19 safety measures in everyday life, the dental profession were grappling with significant changes to their working environment, including PPE, redeployment, use of aerosol generating procedures (AGPs), and timelines for re-opening practices. This longitudinal diary study has shown some parts of the dental profession in Scotland expressed very varied and personal concerns and anxieties related to COVID-19. Respondents' candor in their diary entries revealed explicit, frequent and high levels of uncertainty and worry related to their training and career. Collectively, the data corpus highlighted the emotional toll these anxieties have taken on the dental professions in Scotland.
These findings demonstrate the need for (a) increased provision of mental health and wellbeing support services for dental staff and (b) the study of the linkage between organization of pandemic management to the working practices of staff delivering services. Interventions, at various levels, should take into consideration the fluctuating nature of dental professionals' concerns and anxieties over time, to address both immediate and longer-term issues.
新冠疫情给牙科领域带来了一系列重大变化和调整,牙科专业人员应对了牙科诊所的临时关闭、个人防护设备使用的增加、临床程序的减少以及培训计划的延长。近期研究阐明了疫情对牙科行业的影响,表明许多牙科专业人员感到情绪疲惫,并经历了重大的不确定性和焦虑。这项定性研究旨在了解在苏格兰的牙科实习生和基层牙科护理人员中,这些经历和情绪在六个月的时间里是如何变化的。
对牙科实习生和基层牙科护理人员进行了一项纵向日记研究(2020年6月至12月)。日记要求受访者每周回答三个与他们的情绪疲惫相关的问题。还有一个开放式问题,要求受访者描述由于新冠疫情对他们的工作或培训产生影响,在前一周他们所经历的任何重大问题或担忧。使用轨迹分析方法对这些定性数据进行探索,以具体确定随时间的变化。
轨迹分析揭示了受访者中普遍存在的几个关键担忧,以及它们在六个月中的波动情况。这些担忧包括:疫情对受访者未来职业以及更广泛的牙科领域的影响;适应新的工作环境;对患者牙科治疗和口腔健康的影响;对他们自身健康和幸福的影响;财务方面的考虑以及作为牙科服务恢复工作一部分对新安全措施的适应。
在2020年下半年,随着英国在日常生活中适应新的新冠安全措施的引入,牙科行业正在应对其工作环境的重大变化,包括个人防护设备、人员调配、产生气溶胶程序(AGP)的使用以及诊所重新开业的时间安排。这项纵向日记研究表明,苏格兰牙科行业的一些人员表达了与新冠疫情相关的非常多样和个人化的担忧与焦虑。受访者在日记条目中的坦诚揭示了与他们的培训和职业相关的明显、频繁且高度的不确定性和担忧。总体而言,数据集突出了这些焦虑给苏格兰牙科行业带来的情感代价。
这些发现表明需要(a)为牙科工作人员增加提供心理健康和幸福支持服务,以及(b)研究疫情管理组织与提供服务的工作人员工作实践之间的联系。各级干预措施应考虑到牙科专业人员的担忧和焦虑随时间波动的性质,以解决眼前和长期问题。