Charlton Deborah, Costa Catia, Trindade Gustavo F, Hinder Steve, Watts John F, Bailey Melanie J
Department of Chemistry, University of Surrey, Surrey, Guildford GU2 7XH, UK; Fingerprint Development Laboratory, Thames Valley Police, Kidlington, Oxfordshire OX5 2NX, UK.
Surrey Ion Beam Centre, University of Surrey, Guildford, Surrey GU2 7XH, UK.
Sci Justice. 2023 Jan;63(1):9-18. doi: 10.1016/j.scijus.2022.10.004. Epub 2022 Nov 1.
The processes routinely used by police forces to visualise fingermarks in casework may not provide sufficient ridge pattern quality to aid an investigation. Time of Flight-Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry (ToF-SIMS) has been proposed as a technique to enhance fingermark recovery. The technique is currently designated a Category C process in the Fingermark Visualisation Manual (FVM) as it shows potential for effective fingermark visualisation but has not yet been fully evaluated. Here the sensitivity of ToF-SIMS on three common exhibit-type surfaces - paper, polyethylene and stainless-steel was compared to standard processes. An adapted Home Office grading scale was used to evaluate the efficacy of fingerprint development by ToF-SIMS and to provide a framework for comparison with standard processes. ToF-SIMS was shown to visualise more fingerprints than the respective standard process, for all surfaces tested. In addition, ToF-SIMS was applied after the standard processes and successfully enhanced the fingerprint detail, even when the standard process failed to visualise ridge detail. This demonstrates the benefit for incorporating it into current operational fingermark development workflows. Multivariate analysis (MVA), using simsMVA, was additionally explored as a method to simplify the data analysis and image generation process.
警方在案件处理中常规用于显现指纹的方法可能无法提供足够的纹路图案质量以协助调查。飞行时间二次离子质谱法(ToF-SIMS)已被提议作为一种增强指纹提取的技术。该技术目前在《指纹显现手册》(FVM)中被指定为C类方法,因为它显示出有效显现指纹的潜力,但尚未得到充分评估。在此,将ToF-SIMS在三种常见物证类型表面——纸张、聚乙烯和不锈钢上的灵敏度与标准方法进行了比较。采用了一种改编后的内政部分级标准来评估ToF-SIMS进行指纹显影的效果,并提供一个与标准方法进行比较的框架。结果表明,对于所有测试表面,ToF-SIMS显现出的指纹比相应标准方法更多。此外,在标准方法之后应用ToF-SIMS,即使标准方法未能显现出纹路细节,它也成功增强了指纹细节。这证明了将其纳入当前的实际指纹显影工作流程的益处。还探索了使用simsMVA进行多变量分析(MVA),作为简化数据分析和图像生成过程的一种方法。