Olufunlayo Tolulope F, Ojo Oluwadamilola O, Ozoh Obianuju B, Agabi Osigwe P, Opara Chuks R, Taiwo Funmilola T, Fasanmade Olufemi A, Okubadejo Njideka U
Department of Community Health and Primary Care, Faculty of Clinical Sciences, College of Medicine, University of Lagos, Idi-Araba, Lagos, Nigeria.
Department of Community Health, Lagos University Teaching Hospital, Idi-Araba, Lagos, Nigeria.
Digit Health. 2023 Jan 3;9:20552076221150072. doi: 10.1177/20552076221150072. eCollection 2023 Jan-Dec.
Telemedicine has reinforced its position as a means for the continuity of healthcare services and a cost-effective approach to improving health equity as demonstrated during the COVID-19 pandemic. The preparedness of health systems for telemedicine is an indicator of the scalability of their services, especially during catastrophes. We aimed to assess the maturity and preparedness of federally funded tertiary health institutions in Nigeria, to deploy telemedicine as such data are currently lacking and are required to drive improvements in health services delivery.
We conducted a cross-sectional survey of thirty randomly selected federally funded tertiary health institutions in Nigeria using the Pan American Health Organization's tool for assessing the maturity level of health institutions to implement telemedicine between 17 September 2020 and 1 September 2021. Descriptive statistics were used for overall maturity levels and non-parametric tests to compare scores for overall maturity and specific Pan American Health Organization domains per region. The level of significance was set at -value <0.05.
The response rate was 77.4% (24 of 30 randomly polled federally funded tertiary health institutions responded). Overall, the median telemedicine maturity level was 2.0 (1.75) indicating a beginner level. No significant inter-zonal difference in the median overall maturity level (= 0.87). The median maturity levels for telemedicine readiness in specific domains were organizational readiness - 2.0 (2.0), processes 1.0 (1.0), digital environment 2.0 (3.0), human resources 2.0 (1.0), regulatory issues - 1.5 (1.0) and expertise 2.0 (2.0); mostly at beginner level, with no inter-zonal differences. Most participating institutions had no initiatives in place for domains of processes and regulatory issues.
The current telemedicine maturity level of federally funded tertiary health institutions in Nigeria is at the beginner level. This behoves policy-makers to advance the implementation and deployment of telemedicine nationwide as part of digital quality healthcare, to improve health equity and to ensure continuity of healthcare services in the event of another pandemic.
远程医疗巩固了其作为医疗服务连续性手段以及提高健康公平性的成本效益方法的地位,正如在新冠疫情期间所展示的那样。卫生系统对远程医疗的准备情况是其服务可扩展性的一个指标,尤其是在灾难期间。我们旨在评估尼日利亚联邦资助的三级医疗机构的成熟度和准备情况,因为目前缺乏此类数据,而这些数据对于推动医疗服务提供的改善是必需的。
我们于2020年9月17日至2021年9月1日,使用泛美卫生组织评估医疗机构实施远程医疗成熟度水平的工具,对尼日利亚随机选取的30家联邦资助的三级医疗机构进行了横断面调查。描述性统计用于总体成熟度水平,非参数检验用于比较各地区总体成熟度和泛美卫生组织特定领域的得分。显著性水平设定为p值<0.05。
回复率为77.4%(30家随机调查的联邦资助三级医疗机构中有24家回复)。总体而言,远程医疗成熟度中位数为2.0(1.75),表明处于初级水平。总体成熟度中位数在各区域间无显著差异(p = 0.87)。特定领域远程医疗准备情况的成熟度中位数分别为:组织准备 - 2.0(2.0),流程1.0(1.0),数字环境2.0(3.0),人力资源2.0(1.0),监管问题 - 1.5(1.0),专业知识2.0(2.0);大多处于初级水平,各区域间无差异。大多数参与机构在流程和监管问题领域没有举措。
尼日利亚联邦资助的三级医疗机构目前的远程医疗成熟度处于初级水平。这促使政策制定者将远程医疗的实施和部署在全国范围内推进,作为数字优质医疗的一部分,以改善健康公平性,并确保在另一场大流行时医疗服务的连续性。