Rodríguez-Ortega María, Ortega-Latorre Yolanda, Montano-Navarro Enrique, Casado-Collado Alfonso Jaime, Nguepy François Roger, Damou Fleur
San Juan de Dios Foundation, Madrid, Spain.
Health Sciences, Department of San Juan de Dios School of Nursing and Physical Therapy, Comillas Pontifical University, Madrid, Spain.
J Adv Nurs. 2025 May;81(5):2477-2486. doi: 10.1111/jan.16406. Epub 2024 Aug 18.
Compare the use and trend of a telemedicine tool for clinical advice among nurses and other Cameroonian healthcare providers and explore its feasibility and accessibility.
A comparative observational descriptive study.
The sample includes all telemedicine users who request advice from volunteer medical specialists in Spain on clinical cases through the telemedicine tool "diagnosis assistance" (DA). It consisted of a total of 296 Cameroonian health professionals (59% women), of whom 77 were nurses. The variables in which the trend was explored (2013-2022) were DAs entered by nurses versus other healthcare professionals, compared by primary specialty, comments and documents attached. Feasibility and accessibility were explored through an anonymous survey.
There were 2527 DAs between 2013 and 2022, of which nurses introduced 68%. There is an increasing trend in the nurse/other healthcare providers ratio, with significant differences in the chi-square of the linear trend between 2015 and 2022 (χ = 395.05; df = 7; p < .001). The probability that a DA was requested by nurses (PR >1) was observed in all years except for 2014, 2018 and 2019. The most tele-counselling requested by nurses was in the specialties of internal medicine, obstetrics and gynaecology, and dermatology. The exchange of comments and attachments was mainly conducted among nurses (74.9% and 50.4%, respectively). The users surveyed considered the tool valuable for diagnosis, applicable, with limitations due to cost, Internet quality or lack of time and effective at reducing hospital referrals.
Telemedicine for clinical advice has been used mostly and with increasing tendency by nurses, mainly in internal medicine, gynaecology and dermatology, being a useful and feasible resource that can contribute to improving clinical decision-making by African nurses.
The study addressed the problem of the shortage of health professionals in Central Africa and the search for alternatives that facilitate decision-making in this context. Tele-counselling tools through digital platforms that put Spanish specialists in contact with health professionals in Central Africa are mostly used by nurses working in rural health centres with a growing trend in their use. The research allows us to determine that tele-counselling tools constitute a well-accepted resource, which has a positive impact in environments with a shortage of human health resources, favouring the safety of both the nursing professional, through support in decision-making, and the populations to whom they provide care, who benefit from a multidisciplinary approach to their processes.
The study has adhered to STROBE guidelines.
No Patient or Public Contribution.
比较喀麦隆护士及其他医疗服务提供者使用远程医疗工具获取临床建议的情况及趋势,并探讨其可行性和可及性。
一项比较性观察描述性研究。
样本包括所有通过远程医疗工具“诊断协助”(DA)就临床病例向西班牙志愿医学专家寻求建议的远程医疗用户。共有296名喀麦隆卫生专业人员(59%为女性)参与,其中77名是护士。探究趋势的变量(2013 - 2022年)包括护士与其他医疗专业人员提交的诊断协助申请,按主要专业、评论及所附文件进行比较。通过匿名调查探究可行性和可及性。
2013年至2022年期间有2527份诊断协助申请,其中护士提交的占68%。护士/其他医疗服务提供者的比例呈上升趋势,2015年至2022年线性趋势的卡方检验存在显著差异(χ = 395.05;自由度 = 7;p < .001)。除2014年、2018年和2019年外,各年份均观察到护士提出诊断协助申请的概率(PR >1)。护士寻求远程咨询最多的专业是内科、妇产科和皮肤科。评论和附件的交流主要在护士之间进行(分别为74.9%和50.4%)。接受调查的用户认为该工具对诊断有价值、适用,但因成本、网络质量或时间不足存在局限性,且在减少医院转诊方面有效。
用于临床建议的远程医疗主要由护士使用且呈增加趋势,主要应用于内科、妇科和皮肤科,是一种有用且可行的资源,有助于改善非洲护士的临床决策。
该研究解决了中非卫生专业人员短缺的问题,并寻求在此背景下促进决策的替代方案。通过数字平台使西班牙专家与中非卫生专业人员联系的远程咨询工具,主要由农村卫生中心的护士使用,且使用趋势不断增加。该研究使我们能够确定远程咨询工具是一种被广泛接受的资源,在人力资源短缺的环境中具有积极影响,通过支持决策有利于护理专业人员的安全,也有利于他们所护理的人群,这些人群受益于多学科的诊疗过程。
该研究遵循了STROBE指南。
无患者或公众贡献。