Farmer A, Jackson R, McGuffin P, Storey P
Institute of Psychiatry, London.
Br J Psychiatry. 1987 Mar;150:324-30. doi: 10.1192/bjp.150.3.324.
A study of cerebral ventricular size measured as ventricle to brain ratio (VBR) using computerised tomographic brain scan in chronic schizophrenics provided no support for suggestions that there are significant differences between patients who fall into different clinical subtypes. We found no significant difference in VBR between patients with and without a family history of schizophrenia or between those with or without paranoid symptoms. Applying Crow's classification, contrary to expectations, Type 1 patients had significantly larger ventricles than those with 'mixed' symptomatology (both Type 1 and Type 2 features). We also applied a variety of operational criteria which attempt to define schizophrenia as a whole: of these only Schneider's first-rank symptoms (FRS) yielded conclusive results--FRS-positive patients had significantly larger mean VBR than those without such symptoms. Previously, it has been suggested that ventricular enlargement is more closely associated with 'negative' than with 'positive' symptoms.
一项针对慢性精神分裂症患者的研究,通过计算机断层脑扫描测量脑室大小,并将其表示为脑室与脑的比例(VBR),该研究并不支持以下观点:不同临床亚型的患者之间存在显著差异。我们发现,有精神分裂症家族史和无精神分裂症家族史的患者之间,以及有或无偏执症状的患者之间,VBR均无显著差异。应用克劳的分类方法,与预期相反,1型患者的脑室明显大于具有“混合”症状(兼具1型和2型特征)的患者。我们还应用了各种试图将精神分裂症作为一个整体来定义的操作标准:其中只有施奈德一级症状(FRS)产生了确凿的结果——有FRS的患者平均VBR明显大于没有此类症状的患者。此前有人提出,脑室扩大与“阴性”症状的关联比与“阳性”症状的关联更为密切。