Jabal Mohamed Sobhi, Kallmes David F, Harston George, Campeau Norbert, Schwartz Kara, Messina Steven, Carr Carrie, Benson John, Little Jason, Nagelschneider Alex, Madhavan Ajay, Nasr Deena, Braksick Sherry, Klaas James, Scharf Eugene, Bilgin Cem, Brinjikji Waleed
Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.
Brainomix Limited, Oxford, UK.
Interv Neuroradiol. 2025 Feb;31(1):95-100. doi: 10.1177/15910199221150470. Epub 2023 Jan 17.
Computed tomography (CT) angiography collateral score (CTA-CS) is an important clinical outcome predictor following mechanical thrombectomy for ischemic stroke with large vessel occlusion (LVO). The present multireader study aimed to evaluate the performance of e-CTA software for automated assistance in CTA-CS scoring.
Brain CTA images of 56 patients with anterior LVO were retrospectively processed. Twelve readers of various clinical training, including junior neuroradiologists, senior neuroradiologists, and neurologists graded collateral flow using visual CTA-CS scale in two sessions separated by a washout period. Reference standard was the consensus of three expert readers. Duration of reading time, inter-rater reliability, and statistical comparison of readers' performance metrics were analyzed between the e-CTA assisted and unassisted sessions.
e-CTA assistance resulted in significant increase in mean accuracy (58.6% to 67.5%, p = 0.003), mean F1 score (0.574 to 0.676, p = 0.002), mean precision (58.8% to 68%, p = 0.007), and mean recall (58.7% to 69.9%, p = 0.002), especially with slight filling deficit (CTA-CS 2 and 3). Mean reading time was reduced across all readers (103.4 to 59.7 s, p = 0.001), and inter-rater agreement in CTA-CS assessment was increased (Krippendorff's alpha 0.366 to 0.676). Optimized occlusion laterality detection was also noted with mean accuracy (92.9% to 96.8%, p = 0.009).
Automated assistance for CTA-CS using e-CTA software provided helpful decision support for readers in terms of improving scoring accuracy and reading efficiency for physicians with a range of experience and training backgrounds and leading to significant improvements in inter-rater agreement.
计算机断层扫描(CT)血管造影侧支评分(CTA-CS)是大动脉闭塞(LVO)性缺血性卒中机械取栓术后重要的临床结局预测指标。本多阅片者研究旨在评估电子CTA软件在CTA-CS评分中自动辅助的性能。
回顾性处理56例前循环LVO患者的脑部CTA图像。12名具有不同临床培训背景的阅片者,包括初级神经放射科医生、高级神经放射科医生和神经科医生,使用视觉CTA-CS量表在两个阶段对侧支血流进行分级,两个阶段之间有洗脱期。参考标准为三位专家阅片者的共识。分析电子CTA辅助和非辅助阶段的阅片时间、阅片者间可靠性以及阅片者性能指标的统计比较。
电子CTA辅助使平均准确率显著提高(从58.6%提高到67.5%,p = 0.003)、平均F1分数(从0.574提高到0.676,p = 0.002)、平均精确率(从58.8%提高到68%,p = 0.007)和平均召回率(从58.7%提高到69.9%,p = 0.002),尤其是在轻度充盈缺损(CTA-CS 2和3)时。所有阅片者的平均阅片时间均减少(从103.4秒减少到59.7秒,p = 0.001),CTA-CS评估中的阅片者间一致性增加(Krippendorff's alpha从0.366提高到0.676)。还注意到优化的闭塞侧别检测,平均准确率提高(从92.9%提高到96.8%,p = 0.009)。
使用电子CTA软件对CTA-CS进行自动辅助,为不同经验和培训背景的医生在提高评分准确性和阅片效率方面提供了有益的决策支持,并显著提高了阅片者间一致性。