Aldbis Ahmet, Naal Hady, Kishawi Tarik, Wazni Rim, Abbara Aula
UOSSM (Union of Medical Care and Relief Organisations), Gaziantep, Turkey.
Global Health Institute at the American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon.
Confl Health. 2023 Jan 21;17(1):2. doi: 10.1186/s13031-023-00501-4.
For those with severe conflict-associated wounds which are affected by antimicrobial resistant (AMR) organisms, health systems during protracted conflict are often ill-equipped to respond to their needs. In this study, our aim is to explore the experiences of those with conflict-associated wounds whose wounds have been infected with AMR bacteria and who reside in northwest Syria (NWS). This is with a view to understanding the challenges they face and how the health and humanitarian system can better respond to their needs.
A qualitative research methodology where in-depth interviews were conducted with patients who are known to have AMR organisms infecting conflict-associated wounds was used. Patients were recruited from Bab Al-Hawa hospital in NWS based on pre-set inclusion criteria. They were invited to participate in remote interviews due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. Interviews were conducted during January and February 2021 and transcribed in Arabic before thematic analysis was undertaken to identify key themes and subthemes.
14 in-depth interviews were conducted of which 12 were with men. The age range was 20-49 years. We categorised the findings into 6 themes: i. those related to the mechanism of injury, ii, the impact of the conflict on health system accessibility, iii. experiences of immediate inpatient management, iv. the experience of outpatient and home management, v. the current impact of the injury on participants, and vi. participant perspectives around improving healthcare access for those with conflict-related wounds affected by AMR organisms. Important findings relate to the quality and capacity for both immediate and longer-term care and the psychosocial and socioeconomic impacts of the injuries which many of the participants continue to grapple with.
This is the first exploration through qualitative research of the experiences of those with conflict-affected wounds which are infected with AMR organisms in NWS. Emerging themes as told by participants can help stakeholders, including policy makers, humanitarian organisations and those involved with health system planning in NWS consider gaps in current and future care needs (including livelihood opportunities) for this vulnerable group.
对于那些患有与冲突相关的严重伤口且伤口受到抗菌药物耐药(AMR)微生物影响的人来说,长期冲突期间的卫生系统往往缺乏应对他们需求的能力。在本研究中,我们的目的是探索那些伤口被AMR细菌感染且居住在叙利亚西北部(NWS)的与冲突相关伤口患者的经历。这是为了了解他们面临的挑战以及卫生和人道主义系统如何能更好地满足他们的需求。
采用定性研究方法,对已知有AMR微生物感染与冲突相关伤口的患者进行深入访谈。根据预先设定的纳入标准,从NWS的巴布·哈瓦医院招募患者。由于持续的COVID-19大流行,邀请他们参加远程访谈。访谈于2021年1月和2月进行,并在进行主题分析以确定关键主题和子主题之前转录为阿拉伯语。
进行了14次深入访谈,其中12次是与男性进行的。年龄范围为20至49岁。我们将研究结果分为6个主题:i. 与受伤机制相关的主题;ii. 冲突对卫生系统可及性的影响;iii. 住院即刻管理的经历;iv. 门诊和家庭管理的经历;v. 目前受伤对参与者的影响;vi. 参与者对改善受AMR微生物影响的与冲突相关伤口患者医疗可及性的看法。重要发现涉及即时和长期护理的质量和能力,以及许多参与者仍在应对的伤害所带来的心理社会和社会经济影响。
这是首次通过定性研究探索NWS中伤口被AMR微生物感染的受冲突影响患者的经历。参与者讲述的新出现的主题可以帮助包括政策制定者、人道主义组织以及参与NWS卫生系统规划的人员在内的利益相关者考虑该弱势群体当前和未来护理需求(包括生计机会)方面的差距。