Singh Yolisha
School of Psychiatry, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Psychiatr Psychol Law. 2023 Jan 17;30(1):51-67. doi: 10.1080/13218719.2022.2134229. eCollection 2023.
The minimum age of criminal responsibility in Australia is 10 years. The topic of raising the age of criminal responsibility remains a fraught and challenging field of both study and thought. Despite overwhelming evidence to support an increase in the minimum age of criminal responsibility, there remains a resolute opposition in the majority of States in Australia that this age should be raised. However, the grounds for reconsidering the current position are indeed compelling. This paper expounds the persuasive arguments for raising the minimum age of criminal responsibility by examining the current scientific evidence and opinion. Considerations are explored and the relevant literature examined using the author's framework that decisions should be just, scientific, not racist, humane, cost-effective and generally not ludicrous. Principles for an alternative approach to criminalisation and for managing the harmful behaviour of children are then offered.
澳大利亚的刑事责任最低年龄为10岁。提高刑事责任年龄这一话题在研究和思考领域仍然是一个充满争议且具有挑战性的领域。尽管有大量证据支持提高刑事责任最低年龄,但澳大利亚大多数州仍坚决反对提高这一年龄。然而,重新审视当前立场的理由确实很有说服力。本文通过审视当前的科学证据和观点,阐述了提高刑事责任最低年龄的有说服力的论据。利用作者提出的决策应公正、科学、非种族主义、人道、具有成本效益且总体上不荒谬的框架,探讨了相关考量因素并研究了相关文献。随后提出了一种替代刑事定罪方法以及管理儿童有害行为的原则。