Vitopoulos Nina A, Peterson-Badali Michele, Brown Shelley, Skilling Tracey A
1Applied Psychology and Human Development, Ontario Institute for Studies in Education, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
2Present Address: Child, Youth and Family Program, Center for Addiction and Mental Health, 252 College St., Toronto, Ontario M5T 1R7 Canada.
J Child Adolesc Trauma. 2018 Nov 27;12(3):351-364. doi: 10.1007/s40653-018-0238-4. eCollection 2019 Sep.
Elevated rates of traumatic experience in the juvenile justice population are well established. Nevertheless, the role of trauma and its application to rehabilitation and recidivism in a criminal justice context remains hotly debated, particularly for female youth. The Risk-Need-Responsivity framework, the predominant model for risk assessment and case management in juvenile justice, does not consider trauma to be a risk factor for offending. This study examined- Posttraumatic Stress symptomology, maltreatment history, and childhood adversity - in relation to RNR risk factors for reoffending (criminogenic needs) and recidivism in a sample of female and male juvenile offenders. Rates of PTS symptomology, maltreatment, and childhood adversity were significantly higher in this sample compared to prevalence in the general population. Females were more likely to have experienced maltreatment. Several maltreatment and childhood adversity types were significantly related to criminogenic needs. PTS symptomology and adversity were not significant predictors of recidivism when entered alongside criminogenic needs; however, maltreatment was the strongest predictor of recidivism for both male and female youth in a model that included criminogenic needs. Gender did not moderate the relationship between maltreatment and recidivism. The importance of considering youths' maltreatment history in their rehabilitative care is discussed.
青少年司法系统中较高的创伤经历发生率已得到充分证实。然而,在刑事司法背景下,创伤的作用及其在康复和再犯方面的应用仍存在激烈争论,尤其是对于女性青少年而言。风险-需求-反应性框架是青少年司法中风险评估和案件管理的主要模式,并不认为创伤是犯罪的风险因素。本研究考察了女性和男性青少年罪犯样本中与再犯(犯罪成因需求)和累犯相关的创伤后应激症状、虐待史和童年逆境。与一般人群的患病率相比,该样本中创伤后应激症状、虐待和童年逆境的发生率显著更高。女性更有可能经历过虐待。几种虐待和童年逆境类型与犯罪成因需求显著相关。当与犯罪成因需求一起纳入分析时,创伤后应激症状和逆境并不是累犯的显著预测因素;然而,在一个包含犯罪成因需求的模型中,虐待是男性和女性青少年累犯的最强预测因素。性别并未调节虐待与累犯之间的关系。文中讨论了在青少年康复护理中考虑其虐待史的重要性。