Rothenberg S, Moore E E, Marx J A, Moore F A, McCroskey B L
Department of Surgery, Denver General Hospital, CO 80204.
J Trauma. 1987 Oct;27(10):1101-6. doi: 10.1097/00005373-198710000-00001.
The evolution of selective laparotomy in children sustaining blunt abdominal trauma has been highly controversial. This report describes our experience and policy change during this transitional period. Emergency laparotomies performed in the pediatric age group (less than 14 yr) between 1980 and 1984, based on peritoneal lavage, were reviewed. Of 16 such patients, six (37.5%) had injuries identified at laparotomy necessitating operation, (four greater than Grade III spleen, one hepatic vein, one small bowel). The remaining ten patients (67.5%) had injuries which probably could have been managed nonoperatively (eight less than or equal to Grade II spleen, two less than or equal to Grade II liver). We additionally reviewed 46 peritoneal lavages done in children during 1984, and noted a 100% sensitivity but 86% specificity when considering essential laparotomies. Based on these data, we established a selective management protocol and initiated a prospective study in January 1985. The protocol consisted of: 1) routine peritoneal lavage (DPL) in children at high risk for abdominal injury, 2) immediate laparotomy for DPL positive for blood in conjunction with hemodynamic instability, 3) selective laparotomy for DPL positive for blood in a stable child, additionally evaluated by abdominal CT scan (major mechanism) or liver/spleen scan (minor mechanism), and 4) mandatory laparotomy for DPL effluent positive by criteria other than blood. This policy reduced unnecessary laparotomy, otherwise warranted by DPL, to 18% (2/11); both patients had Grade II splenic injuries. Five children sustaining low-energy trauma were managed nonoperatively following peritoneal aspiration of gross blood with L-S scan confirming minor solid visceral injury.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
儿童钝性腹部创伤中选择性剖腹手术的发展一直存在很大争议。本报告描述了我们在这一过渡时期的经验和政策变化。回顾了1980年至1984年间基于腹腔灌洗在儿科年龄组(小于14岁)进行的急诊剖腹手术。在16例此类患者中,6例(37.5%)在剖腹手术中发现有需要手术治疗的损伤(4例脾损伤大于Ⅲ级,1例肝静脉损伤,1例小肠损伤)。其余10例患者(67.5%)的损伤可能可以非手术治疗(8例脾损伤小于或等于Ⅱ级,2例肝损伤小于或等于Ⅱ级)。我们还回顾了1984年期间对儿童进行的46次腹腔灌洗,并注意到在考虑必要的剖腹手术时,其敏感性为100%,特异性为86%。基于这些数据,我们制定了选择性管理方案,并于1985年1月启动了一项前瞻性研究。该方案包括:1)对腹部损伤高危儿童进行常规腹腔灌洗(DPL);2)DPL血液阳性且伴有血流动力学不稳定者立即剖腹手术;3)DPL血液阳性且病情稳定的儿童,通过腹部CT扫描(主要机制)或肝脏/脾脏扫描(次要机制)进行额外评估后进行选择性剖腹手术;4)DPL流出液除血液外符合其他标准阳性者必须进行剖腹手术。这一政策将原本因DPL而有必要进行的不必要剖腹手术减少到了18%(2/11);这两名患者均为Ⅱ级脾损伤。5名遭受低能量创伤的儿童在腹腔抽出大量血液后经L-S扫描证实有轻微实性内脏损伤,随后进行了非手术治疗。(摘要截短于250字)