Danube Private University Krems, Krems an der Donau, Austria.
Department of Gender-Specific Dentistry, Danube Private University Krems, Krems an der Donau, Austria.
BMC Pediatr. 2023 Jan 28;23(1):45. doi: 10.1186/s12887-022-03805-1.
Practitioner's knowledge and parental perspectives on dental general anaesthesia (GA) have been surveyed separately in the past. But in daily routine both need to collaborate for the benefit of the child. The aim of this paper was to compare parental and practitioner's acceptance of GA with special focus on identifying factors which influence their differences in decision making.
Questionnaires were conducted among 142 participants in a specialized paediatric dental clinic in Germany from February 2020 to February 2021. 51 German practitioners from private practices and clinics participated. Data collection included: age, gender, experience with GA, fear of GA, risk evaluation and indications for GA.
There were no gender related differences in decision making. Emotional factors are present in parents of younger children. Parents are more likely to express fear and uncertainty regarding GA than dentists. Prior experience with GA significantly decreases fears in GA for parents. Both agree that extent of the treatment and low compliance are a suitable indication for GA. Dentists are more likely to accept GA due to a mental disability than parents. Parents were more likely to accept GA than dentists when multiple extractions were needed (regardless of compliance) or acute pain was present.
A significant divergence in risk evaluation, acceptance and decision-making could be found in parents compared to dentists. Influencing factors are previous experience, younger age of the child, lack of knowledge and indication for GA.
过去曾分别调查过从业者对牙科全身麻醉(GA)的知识和家长的看法。但在日常工作中,双方都需要为孩子的利益而合作。本文的目的是比较家长和从业者对 GA 的接受程度,特别关注确定影响他们决策差异的因素。
2020 年 2 月至 2021 年 2 月,在德国一家专门的儿科牙科诊所对 142 名参与者进行了问卷调查。来自私人诊所和诊所的 51 名德国从业者参与了调查。数据收集包括:年龄、性别、GA 经验、对 GA 的恐惧、风险评估和 GA 适应症。
决策方面没有性别差异。年幼孩子的父母存在情绪因素。父母比牙医更有可能对 GA 表示恐惧和不确定。对 GA 的先前经验会显著减少父母对 GA 的恐惧。双方都认为治疗范围广且配合度低是 GA 的合适适应症。由于精神残疾,牙医比家长更有可能接受 GA。当需要多次拔牙(无论配合程度如何)或出现急性疼痛时,父母比牙医更有可能接受 GA。
与牙医相比,家长在风险评估、接受度和决策方面存在明显差异。影响因素包括既往经验、孩子年龄较小、缺乏知识和 GA 适应症。