Ruben Johnson-Pradeep, Shah Henal, Sreedaran Priya, Chandran Suhas, Selvam Sumithra, Kurpad Sunita Simon
Department of Psychiatry, St John's Medical College, Sarjapur Road, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India.
Department of Psychiatry, TNMC and Nair Hospital, Co-Director, GSMC- FAIMER Regional Institute, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India.
Indian J Psychiatry. 2022 Nov-Dec;64(6):545-554. doi: 10.4103/indianjpsychiatry.indianjpsychiatry_954_21. Epub 2022 Nov 30.
Effective teaching methods are important in psychiatry. Previous studies have focused on the assessment of students about the effective teaching methods but not on a self-assessment by teachers.
Primary objective is to evaluate the teachers' and students' perspectives of effective teaching methods in psychiatry for medical undergraduates. Secondary objectives include assessment of the concordance of each item and exploring innovative teaching methods.
A cross-sectional study design used in teachers and medical students from St. John's Medical College, Bangalore (India).
A modified teachers and medical students perspectives of effective psychiatry teaching methods were used.
Differences in continuous variable assessed with independent sample-test and categorical variables with Chi-square test. The Domain scores were divided into tertiles and the highest and lowest tertiles were analyzed.
Both students and teachers had high perspectives on most of the teaching methods. Differences were found in items such as "," "," "," and "." Role play-based and live/simulated patient-based teachings were reported most frequently by both. Significantly, a higher proportion of the 6 term students and a lesser proportion of teachers were associated with the lowest tertiles for Domain 1, 2, and 3. Significantly, increased number of 8 term students were found in the higher tertiles in Domain 3.
These findings have practical implications in identifying the gaps in effective teaching methods by the teachers. Teachers can improve their teaching methods by upgrading their presentation skills, employing new and innovative teaching skills.
有效的教学方法在精神病学中很重要。以往的研究主要集中在评估学生对有效教学方法的看法,而不是教师的自我评估。
主要目的是评估教师和学生对医学本科生精神病学有效教学方法的看法。次要目的包括评估每个项目的一致性并探索创新的教学方法。
采用横断面研究设计,研究对象为印度班加罗尔圣约翰医学院的教师和医学生。
采用经过修改的教师和医学生对有效精神病学教学方法的看法。
连续变量差异用独立样本检验评估,分类变量用卡方检验评估。将领域得分分为三分位数,并对最高和最低三分位数进行分析。
学生和教师对大多数教学方法的评价都很高。在“……”“……”“……”和“……”等项目上发现了差异。基于角色扮演和基于真实/模拟患者的教学被双方提及的频率最高。值得注意的是,在第1、2和3领域的最低三分位数中,6年级学生的比例较高,教师的比例较低。在第3领域的较高三分位数中,8年级学生的数量显著增加。
这些发现对于识别教师在有效教学方法方面的差距具有实际意义。教师可以通过提升其授课技巧、采用新的创新教学技巧来改进教学方法。