Hankamer School of Business, Marketing Department, Baylor University, Waco, Texas, USA.
Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw. 2023 Feb;26(2):80-89. doi: 10.1089/cyber.2022.0117. Epub 2023 Jan 30.
Despite their growing popularity, little research has focused on the association between Instagram and TikTok use and psychological well-being. Informed by Uses and Gratifications Theory, the present study investigates the flow states experienced when using each social media platform and whether these flow states differentially impact user well-being. A flow state is achieved when people are so engrossed in an activity that little else seems to matter to them and they will often continue the activity despite its negative consequences. Based upon a survey of adult Instagram ( = 195, = 38) and TikTok users ( = 225, = 37), the present study identified four unique clusters of users for both platforms based upon the levels of five flow dimensions: focused attention, curiosity, enjoyment, telepresence, and time distortion. Results found that TikTok users reported higher levels of overall flow than Instagram users. TikTok users also reported higher levels of the flow dimensions "enjoyment" and "time distortion." The flow dimension of "telepresence" (immersion in a world created by the social media application) for both TikTok and Instagram users was associated with higher levels of depression and anxiety. These social media may provide an escape from everyday worries for users, although a suboptimal coping strategy. Whether Instagram and TikTok use are but "improved means to an unimproved end" is an important question that requires additional research.
尽管社交媒体平台如 Instagram 和 TikTok 越来越受欢迎,但很少有研究关注它们的使用与心理健康之间的关系。本研究以使用与满足理论为指导,探讨了人们在使用每个社交媒体平台时所经历的流畅状态,以及这些流畅状态是否会对用户的幸福感产生不同的影响。当人们全神贯注于某项活动,以至于其他事情似乎都不重要,并且即使该活动有负面影响,他们也会继续进行该活动时,就会达到流畅状态。基于对成年 Instagram 用户(n=195)和 TikTok 用户(n=225)的调查,本研究根据五个流畅维度(专注注意力、好奇心、享受、身临其境和时间扭曲)的水平,确定了这两个平台上的四个独特用户群体。结果发现,TikTok 用户报告的整体流畅水平高于 Instagram 用户。TikTok 用户还报告了更高的“享受”和“时间扭曲”维度的流畅水平。对于 TikTok 和 Instagram 用户而言,“身临其境”(沉浸在社交媒体应用程序创造的世界中)这一流畅维度与更高的抑郁和焦虑水平相关。这些社交媒体可能为用户提供了逃避日常烦恼的途径,尽管这是一种次优的应对策略。Instagram 和 TikTok 的使用是否只是“改进的手段,而非改进的目的”,这是一个需要进一步研究的重要问题。