Wang Chia-Cheng, Yang Chun-Hsiang Ou, Hsu Chih-Po, Liu Chien-Chun, Yu Jau-Song, Lo Chih-Hong, Fann Wen-Chih, Chen Yen-Chia, Lin Chih Chuan
Department of Traumatology and Emergency Surgery, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Chang Gung University, Taoyuan, Taiwan.
College of Medicine, Chang Gung University, Taoyuan, Taiwan.
J Venom Anim Toxins Incl Trop Dis. 2023 Jan 13;29:e20220027. doi: 10.1590/1678-9199-JVATITD-2022-0027. eCollection 2023.
Bivalent freeze-dried neurotoxic (FN) antivenom has been the primary treatment since the 1980s for Taiwan cobra () envenomation in Taiwan. However, envenomation-related wound necrosis is a significant problem after cobra snakebites. In the present study, we analyzed the changes in serum venom concentration before and after antivenom administration to discover their clinical implications and the surgical treatment options for wound necrosis.
The patients were divided into limb swelling and wound necrosis groups. The clinical outcome was that swelling started to subside 12 hours after antivenom treatment in the first group. Serum venom concentrations before and after using antivenoms were measured to assess the antivenom's ability to neutralize the circulating cobra venom. The venom levels in wound wet dressing gauzes, blister fluids, and debrided tissues were also investigated to determine their clinical significance. We also observed the evolutional changes of wound necrosis and chose a better wound debridement timing.
We prospectively enrolled 15 Taiwan cobra snakebite patients. Males accounted for most of this study population (n = 11, 73%). The wound necrosis group received more antivenom doses than the limb swelling group (4; IQR:2-6 vs 1; IQR:1-2, p = 0.05), and less records of serum venom concentrations changed before/after antivenom use (p = 0.0079). The necrotic wound site may release venom into circulation and cause more severe envenomation symptoms. Antivenom can efficiently diminish limb swelling in cobra bite patients. However, antivenom cannot reduce wound necrosis. Patients with early debridement of wound necrosis had a better limb outcome, while late or without debridement may have long-term hospital stay and distal limb morbidity.
Antivenom can efficiently eliminate the circulating cobra venom in limb swelling patients without wound necrosis. Early debridement of the bite site wound and wet dressing management are suggestions for preventing extended tissue necrosis and hospital stay.
自20世纪80年代以来,双价冻干神经毒性(FN)抗蛇毒血清一直是台湾地区治疗眼镜蛇咬伤的主要方法。然而,眼镜蛇咬伤后与毒液相关的伤口坏死是一个严重问题。在本研究中,我们分析了抗蛇毒血清给药前后血清毒液浓度的变化,以发现其临床意义以及伤口坏死的手术治疗选择。
将患者分为肢体肿胀组和伤口坏死组。临床结果是,第一组在抗蛇毒血清治疗12小时后肿胀开始消退。测量使用抗蛇毒血清前后的血清毒液浓度,以评估抗蛇毒血清中和循环中眼镜蛇毒液的能力。还研究了伤口湿敷料纱布、水疱液和清创组织中的毒液水平,以确定其临床意义。我们还观察了伤口坏死的演变变化,并选择了更好的伤口清创时机。
我们前瞻性纳入了15例台湾眼镜蛇咬伤患者。该研究人群中男性占大多数(n = 11,73%)。伤口坏死组比肢体肿胀组接受了更多的抗蛇毒血清剂量(4;四分位数间距:2 - 6 vs 1;四分位数间距:1 - 2,p = 0.05),并且抗蛇毒血清使用前后血清毒液浓度变化的记录更少(p = 0.0079)。坏死伤口部位可能会将毒液释放到循环中,导致更严重的中毒症状。抗蛇毒血清可以有效减轻眼镜蛇咬伤患者的肢体肿胀。然而,抗蛇毒血清不能减少伤口坏死。伤口坏死早期清创的患者肢体预后较好,而晚期或未清创可能导致长期住院和肢体远端发病。
抗蛇毒血清可以有效清除无伤口坏死的肢体肿胀患者循环中的眼镜蛇毒液。咬伤部位伤口的早期清创和湿敷料处理是预防组织坏死扩展和缩短住院时间的建议措施。