Dahal Arati, Kardonsky Kim, Cunningham Matthew, Evans David V, Keys Toby
A. Dahal is a research scientist, Center for Health Workforce Studies, Department of Family Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington.
K. Kardonsky is assistant professor, Department of Family Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington.
Acad Med. 2023 Nov 1;98(11):1288-1293. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000005162. Epub 2023 Feb 1.
There is a persistent rural physician shortage in the United States. Policies to scale up the health workforce in response to this shortage must include measures to draw and maintain existing and newly trained health care workers to rural regions. Prior studies have found that experience in community medicine in rural practice settings increases the likelihood of medical graduates practicing in those regions but have not accounted for selection bias. This study examined the impact of a community-based clinical immersion program on medical graduates' decision to work in rural regions, adjusting for covariates to control for selection bias.
Data on sociodemographic characteristics and career interests and preferences for all 1,172 University of Washington School of Medicine graduates between 2009 and 2014 were collected. A logistic model (model 1) was used to evaluate the impact of Rural Underserved Opportunities Program (RUOP) participation on the probability of physicians working in a rural region. Another model (model 2) included the propensity score as a covariate in the regression to control for possible confounding based on differences among those who did and did not participate in the RUOP.
Of the 994 students included in the analysis, 570 (57.3%) participated in RUOP training, and 111 (11.2%) were currently working in rural communities after their training. Regression analysis results showed that the odds of working in a rural region were 1.83 times higher for graduates who participated in RUOP in model 1 ( P = .03) and 1.77 times higher in model 2 ( P = .04).
The findings of this study emphasize that educational programs and policies are crucial public health interventions that can promote health equity through proper distribution of health care workers across rural regions of the United States.
美国农村地区长期存在医生短缺的问题。为应对这一短缺而扩大卫生人力的政策必须包括吸引和留住现有及新培训的医护人员到农村地区的措施。先前的研究发现,在农村实践环境中积累社区医学经验会增加医学毕业生在这些地区执业的可能性,但未考虑选择偏差。本研究考察了一项基于社区的临床沉浸式项目对医学毕业生在农村地区工作决策的影响,并调整协变量以控制选择偏差。
收集了2009年至2014年间华盛顿大学医学院1172名毕业生的社会人口学特征、职业兴趣和偏好数据。使用逻辑模型(模型1)评估参与农村服务不足机会项目(RUOP)对医生在农村地区工作概率的影响。另一个模型(模型2)在回归中纳入倾向得分作为协变量,以控制基于参与和未参与RUOP者之间差异可能产生的混杂因素。
纳入分析的994名学生中,570名(57.3%)参加了RUOP培训,111名(11.2%)在培训后目前在农村社区工作。回归分析结果显示,在模型1中,参与RUOP的毕业生在农村地区工作的几率高1.83倍(P = 0.03),在模型2中高1.77倍(P = 0.04)。
本研究结果强调,教育项目和政策是至关重要的公共卫生干预措施,可通过在美国农村地区合理分配医护人员来促进健康公平。