Verma Neha, Lehmann Harold, Alam Amal Afroz, Yazdi Youseph, Acharya Soumyadipta
Division of Health Sciences Informatics, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, United States.
Intelehealth, Baltimore, MD, United States.
JMIR Hum Factors. 2023 Feb 2;10:e25361. doi: 10.2196/25361.
Many low- and middle-income countries have adopted telemedicine programs that connect frontline health workers (FHWs) such as nurses, midwives, or community health workers in rural and remote areas with physicians in urban areas to deliver care to patients. By leveraging technology to reduce temporal, financial, and geographical barriers, these health worker-to-physician telemedicine programs have the potential to increase health care quality, expand the specialties available to patients, and reduce the time and cost required to deliver care.
We aimed to identify, validate, and prioritize unmet needs in the health care space of health worker-to-physician telemedicine programs and develop and refine a solution that addresses those needs.
We collected information regarding user needs through ethnographic research, direct observation, and semistructured interviews with 37 stakeholders (n=5, 14% physicians; n=1, 3% public health program manager; n=12, 32% community health workers; and n=19, 51% patients) at 2 telemedicine clinics in rural West Bengal, India. We used the Spiral-Iterative Innovation Model to design and develop a prototype solution to meet these needs.
We identified 74 unmet needs through our immersion in health worker-to-physician telemedicine programs. We identified a critical unmet need that achieving optimal teleconsultations in low- and middle-income countries often requires shifting tasks such as history taking and physical examination from high-skilled remote physicians to FHWs. To meet this need, we developed a prototype digital assistant that would allow FHWs to assume some of the tasks carried out by remote clinicians. The user needs of multiple stakeholder groups (patients, FHWs, physicians, and health organizations) were incorporated into the design and features of the task-shifting tool. The final prototype was shared with the health workers, physicians, and public health program managers who expressed that the tool would be useful and valuable.
The final prototype that was developed was released as an open-source digital public good and may improve the quality and efficiency of care delivery in health worker-to-physician telemedicine programs.
许多低收入和中等收入国家都采用了远程医疗项目,这些项目将农村和偏远地区的一线卫生工作者(如护士、助产士或社区卫生工作者)与城市地区的医生联系起来,为患者提供护理。通过利用技术减少时间、经济和地理障碍,这些卫生工作者与医生之间的远程医疗项目有可能提高医疗质量,扩大患者可获得的专科服务范围,并减少提供护理所需的时间和成本。
我们旨在识别、验证并优先处理卫生工作者与医生远程医疗项目医疗保健领域未满足的需求,并开发和完善满足这些需求的解决方案。
我们通过人种志研究、直接观察以及对印度西孟加拉邦农村地区两家远程医疗诊所的37名利益相关者(5名医生,占14%;1名公共卫生项目经理,占3%;12名社区卫生工作者,占32%;19名患者,占51%)进行半结构化访谈,收集了有关用户需求的信息。我们使用螺旋迭代创新模型来设计和开发一个原型解决方案以满足这些需求。
通过深入参与卫生工作者与医生远程医疗项目,我们识别出了74项未满足的需求。我们确定了一项关键的未满足需求,即在低收入和中等收入国家实现最佳远程会诊通常需要将病史采集和体格检查等任务从高技能的远程医生转移到一线卫生工作者身上。为满足这一需求,我们开发了一个原型数字助手,使一线卫生工作者能够承担一些由远程临床医生执行的任务。多个利益相关者群体(患者、一线卫生工作者、医生和卫生组织)的用户需求被纳入了任务转移工具的设计和功能中。最终的原型已与卫生工作者、医生和公共卫生项目经理分享,他们表示该工具将是有用且有价值的。
所开发的最终原型作为一种开源数字公益产品发布,可能会提高卫生工作者与医生远程医疗项目中护理服务的质量和效率。