Postgraduate Program of Nutrition, Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte, Natal, Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil.
Faculty of Health Sciences of Trairi, Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte, Santa Cruz, Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil.
PLoS One. 2023 Feb 6;18(2):e0280725. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0280725. eCollection 2023.
Traditional methods to assess dietary intake have limited and questionable application in visually impaired people since the lack of vision and low leading role in their diet make it difficult to quantify and detail the food consumed throughout the day. Thus, this study investigated whether it is possible to accurately identify foods and estimate their quantities using food records based on photographic images captured by visually impaired people. A panel of experts composed of nutritionists (n = 20) assessed these records comprising three standardized meals (breakfast; lunch/dinner; snack) from visually impaired people (n = 40) using two different protocols (frontal photo; aerial photo). Each nutritionist reported an estimated food record for each photographic image, which was compared to its respective weighed food record. For both frontal and aerial photos, experts were frequently correct for the number of food items in the meal (95.0% or over for breakfast, 100% for lunch/dinner, and 100% for snacks). All experts identified at least 11 of the 13 food items, but the majority correctly estimated the food amount only for 23% of the items. Compared to the weighed food record, the photographic records underestimated the amount of 61.5% of food items based on frontal photos, and of 76.9% of food items based on aerial photos. While most foods could be identified by photographic images captured by visually impaired people enabling a qualitative assessment of the diet, they could not be quantified accurately by nutritionists.
传统的饮食摄入量评估方法在视力障碍者中应用有限且存在疑问,因为视力缺失和在饮食中扮演的次要角色使得难以量化和详细描述全天摄入的食物。因此,本研究旨在探讨视力障碍者是否可以通过基于他们拍摄的照片的食物记录来准确识别食物并估计其数量。一组由营养师组成的专家(n=20)使用两种不同的协议(正面照片;航拍照片)评估了这 40 名视力障碍者的三份标准化餐点(早餐、午餐/晚餐、零食)的食物记录。每位营养师根据每张照片报告了一个估计的食物记录,然后将其与相应的称重食物记录进行比较。对于正面和航拍照片,专家对于餐点中的食物种类数的判断通常是正确的(早餐为 95.0%或以上,午餐/晚餐为 100%,零食为 100%)。所有专家都至少识别出 13 种食物中的 11 种,但只有 23%的食物种类被大多数专家正确估计了食物量。与称重食物记录相比,基于正面照片的照片记录低估了 61.5%的食物种类的数量,而基于航拍照片的记录则低估了 76.9%的食物种类的数量。虽然视力障碍者拍摄的照片可以识别出大多数食物,从而能够对饮食进行定性评估,但营养师无法准确地对其进行量化。