Department of Nutrition, Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte, Avenida Senador Salgado Filho, 3.000, University Campus, Lagoa Nova, Natal59.058-970, RN, Brazil.
Faculty of Health Sciences of Trairí, Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte, Santa Cruz, RN, Brazil.
Public Health Nutr. 2021 Apr;24(5):903-913. doi: 10.1017/S136898002000511X. Epub 2021 Jan 7.
To develop and validate protocols for photographed food record directed to visually impaired people.
Photographic techniques were established for capturing food images using a smartphone, and written protocols were defined. Thereafter, visually impaired people made photographic records of three standardised meals (breakfast, lunch/dinner, and snack) following the previously developed protocols. These photographs were then evaluated by a panel of experts (nutritionists and photographer) to indicate whether the framing, focus and angle were suitable to identify the food type, food amount and portion size. Agreement between the experts was assessed using Fleiss' Kappa.
Natal, the capital of Rio Grande do Norte, Brazil.
Visually impaired people (n 40); nutritionists (n 2); professional photographer (n 1).
Both protocols obtained a high proportion of satisfactory photos for all the items in the three dimensions investigated. When overall quality was assessed, the experts' agreement was a substantial that through the images it would be possible to identify the food type and portion size, both for Frontal Photos (k = 0·70 and k = 0·62, respectively) and Aerial Photos (k = 0·68 and k = 0·70, respectively). The degree of agreement that the photos presented a satisfactory global quality was moderate for the Frontal Photo (k = 0·43) and substantial for the Aerial Photo (k = 0·64). Participants who frequently used smartphone-type cell phones obtained better quality images for all these attributes for both protocols.
The protocols for photographed food record developed for visually impaired people in this study are feasible and present themselves as an alternative strategy to qualitatively assess their dietary intake.
为视障人士开发并验证照片食物记录方案。
使用智能手机拍摄食物图像的摄影技术已建立,并且已定义书面方案。此后,视障人士按照先前制定的方案拍摄了三份标准化餐点(早餐、午餐/晚餐和零食)的照片记录。然后,由一组专家(营养师和摄影师)对这些照片进行评估,以指示取景、焦点和角度是否适合识别食物类型、食物量和份量大小。使用 Fleiss' Kappa 评估专家之间的一致性。
巴西北里奥格兰德州首府纳塔尔。
视障人士(n = 40);营养师(n = 2);专业摄影师(n = 1)。
两种方案对于三个维度调查的所有项目都获得了很高比例的满意照片。当评估整体质量时,专家的一致性为中等偏强,通过这些图像可以识别食物类型和份量大小,无论是正面照片(k = 0.70 和 k = 0.62)还是航拍照片(k = 0.68 和 k = 0.70)。对于正面照片(k = 0.43)和航拍照片(k = 0.64),照片具有令人满意的整体质量的一致性程度为中等偏强。经常使用智能手机类型手机的参与者在这两种方案中对于所有这些属性都能获得更好质量的图像。
本研究中为视障人士开发的照片食物记录方案是可行的,并提出了一种定性评估其饮食摄入量的替代策略。