Department of Psychiatry, Columbia University Irving Medical Center, New York, NY.
Department of Pediatrics, Columbia University Irving Medical Center, New York, NY.
Genet Med. 2023 May;25(5):100801. doi: 10.1016/j.gim.2023.100801. Epub 2023 Feb 4.
With the growing use of genetic testing in medicine, the question of when genetic findings should be reinterpreted in light of new data has become inescapable. The generation of population and disease-specific data, development of computational tools, and new understandings of the relationship of specific genes to disorders can all trigger changes in variant classification that may have important implications for patients and the clinicians caring for them. This is a particular concern for patients from groups underrepresented in current reference datasets, since they have higher rates of uncertain findings. Here we identify the challenges to implementing a systematic approach to variant reinterpretation and propose solutions. In particular, we address (a) the infrastructure needed to support implementation of systematic variant reinterpretation, (b) the issues around obtaining consent from patients for reinterpretation, (c) the process for triggering reinterpretation, (d) pathways for the flow of reinterpreted data, (e) considerations for how to cover the costs of reinterpretation, and (f) practical issues related to implementation of processes and policies that address these issues, including the importance of a fixed duration during which there is an expectation that variants will be reinterpreted.
随着基因检测在医学中的应用日益广泛,何时应根据新数据重新解释基因检测结果的问题已不可回避。人群和疾病特异性数据的产生、计算工具的开发以及特定基因与疾病关系的新认识,都可能引发变异分类的变化,这可能对患者及其照顾者的临床医生产生重要影响。对于当前参考数据集代表性不足的患者群体来说,这尤其令人关注,因为他们的不确定发现率更高。在这里,我们确定了实施系统的变异重新解释方法所面临的挑战,并提出了解决方案。特别是,我们讨论了(a)支持系统的变异重新解释实施所需的基础设施,(b)获得患者同意重新解释的问题,(c)触发重新解释的过程,(d)重新解释数据的流动途径,(e)考虑如何承担重新解释的费用,以及(f)与实施解决这些问题的流程和政策相关的实际问题,包括在重新解释的预期时间内固定不变的重要性。