Department of Ophthalmology, Kindai University, Osakasayama 589-8511, Japan.
Int J Mol Sci. 2023 Jan 30;24(3):2611. doi: 10.3390/ijms24032611.
Smear microscopic examination and culture of the corneal scrapings are the gold standards for the diagnosis of bacterial keratoconjunctivitis. High-sensitivity molecular biological examinations of the ocular surface specimens are used clinically. However, the results require careful interpretation to avoid the unintentional detection of indigenous bacteria. Results of conventional and state-of-the-art examinations require clinical verification for specificity and sensitivity. In this study, smear microscopic examination, culture, and nanopore sequencing using the MinION of ocular surface specimens from eight clinically diagnosed bacterial keratoconjunctivitis cases were performed and compared. Seven of the eight cases (87.5%) were smear positive and five (62.5%) were culture positive. The former showed the same genus in >60% of the classified reads as one specific bacterium inferred from the smear microscopy when sequenced by the MinION. In two of the three culture-negative cases, the smear-positive images were highly reminiscent of the species comprising most of the MinION sequences. Four of the five culture-positive cases were consistent with the most prevalent bacteria in the sequencing results. Probable contamination among specimens processed on the same day were observed. In conclusion, the microscopic examination of the corneal scraping specimens may be more sensitive and specific than the culture examination. Additionally, although metagenomic analysis using the MinION contributes to more precise medication for bacterial keratoconjunctivitis, contamination can affect the results.
角膜刮片的涂片显微镜检查和培养是细菌性角膜炎诊断的金标准。临床上使用高灵敏度的眼表标本分子生物学检查。然而,为了避免无意中检测到本土细菌,需要仔细解释结果。传统和最先进的检查结果需要临床验证其特异性和敏感性。在这项研究中,对 8 例临床诊断为细菌性角膜炎的眼表标本进行了涂片显微镜检查、培养和 MinION 的纳米孔测序,并进行了比较。8 例中有 7 例(87.5%)涂片阳性,5 例(62.5%)培养阳性。前者在 MinION 测序时,有超过 60%的分类读数与涂片显微镜推断的一种特定细菌的属相同。在 3 例培养阴性的病例中,涂片阳性的图像与构成 MinION 序列大部分的物种高度相似。5 例培养阳性的病例中有 4 例与测序结果中最常见的细菌一致。在同一天处理的标本中观察到可能的污染。总之,角膜刮片标本的显微镜检查可能比培养检查更敏感和特异。此外,虽然使用 MinION 进行的宏基因组分析有助于更精确地治疗细菌性角膜炎,但污染会影响结果。