Department of Neurosurgery, Sainte-Anne Hospital, Paris, France; Paris Descartes University, Sorbonne Paris Cité, Paris, France.
Department of Neurosurgery, Friedrich-Schiller University, Jena, Germany; Medical Affairs Neuromodulation International, LivaNova PLC, London, United Kingdom.
Neurochirurgie. 2023 May;69(3):101420. doi: 10.1016/j.neuchi.2023.101420. Epub 2023 Feb 10.
Vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) therapy has been used for more than two decades to treat drug resistant epilepsy and depression and most recently received FDA approval for stroke rehabilitation. Expanding indications will renew the interest in the technique and increase the number of surgeons to be trained. The aim of this study was to survey surgeons with substantial expertise on optimal teaching and training approaches.
Anonymous forms comprising 16 questions were sent by e-mail to surgeons with substantial expertise. Statistical analyses were used to compare the answers of the most experienced surgeons (>5 years) with the less experienced ones (<5 years).
Fully-completed forms were collected from 57 experts from 20 countries. The placement of the helical coils was deemed to be the most difficult step by 36 (63.2%) experts, and the use of optical magnification during this step was deemed necessary by 39 (68.4%) experts. Vocal cord palsy should be largely avoidable with proper surgical technique according to 44 (77.2%) experts. The teaching tool considered the most useful was mentoring (38, 66.7%). The future of VNS surgery teaching was deemed to be in anatomical workshops (29, 50.9%) and surgical simulation (26, 45.6%). Overall, answers did not vary significantly according to experience.
VNS surgery should be mastered by actively participating in dedicated practical training courses and by individual mentoring during actual surgery, which is still the best way to learn. This study highlights the need for a formal training course and possible specific accreditation.
迷走神经刺激(VNS)疗法已被用于治疗耐药性癫痫和抑郁症超过二十年,最近还获得了 FDA 对中风康复的批准。扩大适应症将重新引起人们对该技术的兴趣,并增加需要培训的外科医生数量。本研究旨在调查具有丰富经验的外科医生,以了解他们对最佳教学和培训方法的看法。
通过电子邮件向具有丰富经验的外科医生发送了包含 16 个问题的匿名表格。统计分析用于比较经验丰富的外科医生(>5 年)和经验不足的外科医生(<5 年)的答案。
从 20 个国家的 57 名专家那里收集到了完整填写的表格。36 名(63.2%)专家认为螺旋线圈的放置是最困难的步骤,39 名(68.4%)专家认为在这一步骤中使用光学放大是必要的。44 名(77.2%)专家认为,通过正确的手术技术,可以很大程度上避免声带麻痹。38 名(66.7%)专家认为指导是最有用的教学工具。未来的 VNS 手术教学被认为是在解剖学工作坊(29,50.9%)和手术模拟(26,45.6%)中进行。总体而言,答案根据经验没有明显差异。
VNS 手术应通过积极参加专门的实践培训课程和实际手术中的个人指导来掌握,这仍然是学习的最佳方式。本研究强调了需要正式的培训课程和可能的特定认证。