Lans Amanda, Bales John R, Fourman Mitchell S, Borkhetaria Pranati P, Verlaan Jorrit-Jan, Schwab Joseph H
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
HSS J. 2023 Feb;19(1):120-127. doi: 10.1177/15563316221110536. Epub 2022 Jul 15.
Limited health literacy has been associated with adverse health outcomes. Undergoing orthopedic surgery often requires patients to make complex decisions and adhere to complicated instructions, suggesting that health literacy skills might have a profound impact on orthopedic surgery outcomes. : We sought to review the literature for studies investigating the level of health literacy in patients undergoing orthopedic surgery and also to assess how those studies report factors affecting health equity. : We conducted a systematic search of PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane Library for all health literacy studies published in the orthopedic surgery literature up to February 8, 2022. Search terms included synonyms for health literacy and for all orthopedic surgery subspecialties. Two reviewers independently extracted study data in addition to indicators of equity reporting using the PROGRESS+ checklist (Place of Residence, Race/Ethnicity, Occupation, Gender/sex, Religion, Education, Social capital, Socioeconomic status, plus age, disability, and sexual orientation). : The search resulted in 616 studies; 9 studies remained after exclusion criteria were applied. Most studies were of arthroplasty (4/9; 44%) or trauma (3/9; 33%) patients. Validated health literacy assessments were used in 4 of the included studies, and only 3 studies reported the rate of limited health literacy in the patients studied, which ranged between 34% and 38.5%. At least one PROGRESS+ item was reported in 88% (8/9) of the studies. : We found a paucity of appropriately designed studies that used validated measures of health literacy in the field of orthopedic surgery. The potential impact of health literacy on orthopedic patients and their outcomes has yet to be elucidated. Thoughtful, high-quality trials across diverse demographics and geographies are warranted.
健康素养有限与不良健康结果相关。接受骨科手术通常要求患者做出复杂的决策并遵循复杂的医嘱,这表明健康素养技能可能对骨科手术结果产生深远影响。我们试图回顾文献,以研究接受骨科手术患者的健康素养水平,并评估这些研究如何报告影响健康公平的因素。我们对PubMed、Embase和Cochrane图书馆进行了系统检索,以查找截至2022年2月8日发表在骨科手术文献中的所有健康素养研究。检索词包括健康素养的同义词以及所有骨科手术亚专业的同义词。除了使用PROGRESS+清单(居住地、种族/民族、职业、性别/性、宗教、教育、社会资本、社会经济地位,加上年龄、残疾和性取向)报告公平性指标外,两名 reviewers 独立提取了研究数据。检索结果为616项研究;应用排除标准后,剩下9项研究。大多数研究针对的是关节置换术(4/9;44%)或创伤(3/9;33%)患者。纳入的4项研究使用了经过验证的健康素养评估,只有3项研究报告了所研究患者中健康素养有限的比例,范围在34%至38.5%之间。88%(8/9)的研究报告了至少一项PROGRESS+项目。我们发现,在骨科手术领域,缺乏设计合理且使用经过验证的健康素养测量方法的研究。健康素养对骨科患者及其手术结果的潜在影响尚未阐明。有必要在不同人口统计学和地域范围内进行深入、高质量的试验。