MRC Centre for Global Infectious Disease Analysis & WHO Collaborating Centre for Infectious Disease Modelling, Jameel Institute for Disease and Emergency Analytics, Imperial College London, United Kingdom.
MRC Centre for Global Infectious Disease Analysis & WHO Collaborating Centre for Infectious Disease Modelling, Jameel Institute for Disease and Emergency Analytics, Imperial College London, United Kingdom; Eijkman-Oxford Clinical Research Unit, Jakarta, Indonesia.
Vaccine. 2023 Mar 10;41(11):1885-1891. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.01.068. Epub 2023 Feb 1.
To estimate the expected socio-economic value of booster vaccination in terms of averted deaths and averted closures of businesses and schools using simulation modelling.
The value of booster vaccination in Indonesia is estimated by comparing simulated societal costs under a twelve-month, 187-million-dose Moderna booster vaccination campaign to costs without boosters. The costs of an epidemic and its mitigation consist of lost lives, economic closures and lost education; cost-minimising non-pharmaceutical mitigation is chosen for each scenario.
The cost-minimising non-pharmaceutical mitigation depends on the availability of vaccines: the differences between the two scenarios are 14 to 19 million years of in-person education and $153 to $204 billion in economic activity. The value of the booster campaign ranges from $2,500 ($1,400-$4,100) to $2,800 ($1,700-$4,600) per dose in the first year, depending on life-year valuations.
The societal benefits of booster vaccination are substantial. Much of the value of vaccination resides in the reduced need for costly non-pharmaceutical mitigation. We propose cost minimisation as a tool for policy decision-making and valuation of vaccination, taking into account all socio-economic costs, and not averted deaths alone.
通过模拟建模,估算在避免死亡和避免企业及学校关闭方面,加强针接种的预期社会经济效益。
通过比较在为期 12 个月、接种 1.87 亿剂 Moderna 加强针的模拟社会成本与没有加强针的情况下的成本,估算印度尼西亚加强针接种的价值。疫情及其缓解措施的成本包括生命损失、经济关闭和教育损失;每个场景都选择了成本最小化的非药物缓解措施。
成本最小化的非药物缓解措施取决于疫苗的供应情况:两种情况下的差异为 1400 万至 1900 万年面对面教育和 1530 亿至 2040 亿美元的经济活动。在第一年,加强针接种的价值为每剂 2500 美元(1400 美元至 4100 美元)至 2800 美元(1700 美元至 4600 美元),具体取决于生命年的估值。
加强针接种的社会效益巨大。疫苗接种的大部分价值在于减少对昂贵的非药物缓解措施的需求。我们建议将成本最小化作为政策决策和疫苗接种估值的工具,同时考虑到所有社会经济成本,而不仅仅是避免死亡。