Trauma Unit and Emergency Department, IRCCS Galeazzi Orthopedics Institute.
Trauma Unit and Emergency Department, IRCCS Galeazzi Orthopedics Institute, Milano, Italy.
Acta Biomed. 2023 Feb 13;94(1):e2023066. doi: 10.23750/abm.v94i1.14146.
Spinal Cord Injury without Radiographic Abnormality (SCIWORA) represents acute traumatic myelopathy in the absence of instrumental evidence of fractures and/or dislocations of the cervical vertebrae.
In this article we present 4 cases of SCIWORA that came to our observation and the medico-legal implications associated with them.
In defining the compensation in the context of a private accident policy for traumatic pathologies of the spinal cord, an in-depth medical-legal assessment is essential, based on an accurate examination of the health documentation including the instrumental investigations performed, the anamnesis and an accurate evaluation of the trauma dynamic. The paraphysiological deterioration of organ-tissue structures, identifiable in the concept of "natural variability of biological risk", should be included in the same definition of insured risk by age group, with the consequence that physical conditions that fall within the physiological or paraphysiological definitions, although potentially contributing to injury, do not necessarily exclude compensation. A different concept dominates the variability of the compensation according to a paraphysiological pre-existing condition. The two arguments therefore call for thorough consideration of both the paraphysiological contributing causes of injury and/or impairment as necessarily subject to a preliminary study, which through the clinical and instrumental investigation method, will define the perimeter of functionality.
无放射学异常的脊髓损伤(SCIWORA)代表了颈椎无骨折和/或脱位的影像学证据的急性创伤性脊髓病。
本文介绍了我们观察到的 4 例 SCIWORA 病例以及与之相关的医学法律影响。
在定义涉及脊髓创伤性病变的私人事故保险赔偿时,必须进行深入的医学法律评估,这基于对健康文件的准确检查,包括进行的仪器检查、病史以及对创伤动态的准确评估。在“生物风险自然变异”的概念中,可识别出器官-组织结构的病理性恶化,应将其纳入按年龄组定义的保险风险范围内,因此,尽管可能导致受伤,但属于生理或病理性定义范围内的身体状况不一定排除赔偿。根据预先存在的病理性条件的变化,另一种概念主导着赔偿的变化。因此,这两个论点都需要彻底考虑受伤和/或损伤的病理性促成因素,作为必要的初步研究,通过临床和仪器检查方法,将确定功能的范围。