Shekhar Aditya C, Blumen Ira J
Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, New YorkUSA.
Center for Bioethics, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MassachusettsUSA.
Prehosp Disaster Med. 2023 Apr;38(2):259-263. doi: 10.1017/S1049023X23000134. Epub 2023 Feb 16.
Currently, many airplanes and helicopters are used as air ambulances to transport high-acuity patients. Unfortunately, civilian air medical transport in the United States has experienced a significant number of serious and fatal accidents. At the moment, additional research is needed to identify what factors affect air medical safety.
Accident reports from the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) were queried. Accident reports were analyzed if the accident occurred from 2000 through 2020, involved a helicopter or airplane on an air medical flight (as identified by the NTSB), and had at least one fatality. The date of the accident, the model of aircraft involved, and NTSB-determined probable causes of the accident were examined.
Eighty-seven (87) accidents and 239 fatalities took place from January 2000 through December 2020. Nearly three-fourths (72.4%) of fatalities occurred on helicopters, while just 27.6% occurred on airplanes. Interpreting the NTSB findings, various human factors probably contributed to 87.4% of fatalities. These include pilot disorientation, pilot errors, maintenance errors, impairment, fatigue, or weather misestimation. Nighttime-related factors probably contributed to 38.9% of fatalities, followed by weather-related factors (35.6%), and various mechanical failures (17.2%).
These data show that the probable causes of fatal air medical accidents are primarily human factors and are, therefore, likely preventable. Developing a safety-first culture with a focus on human factors training has been shown to improve outcomes across a wide range of medical specialties (eg, anesthesia, surgery, and resuscitation). While there have been fewer fatal accidents in recent years, a continued emphasis on various training modalities seems warranted.
目前,许多飞机和直升机被用作空中救护车来运送重症患者。不幸的是,美国民用空中医疗运输发生了大量严重和致命事故。目前,需要更多研究来确定哪些因素会影响空中医疗安全。
查询了美国国家运输安全委员会(NTSB)的事故报告。如果事故发生在2000年至2020年期间,涉及空中医疗飞行的直升机或飞机(由NTSB确定),且至少有一人死亡,则对事故报告进行分析。检查事故日期、所涉飞机型号以及NTSB确定的事故可能原因。
2000年1月至2020年12月期间发生了87起事故,造成239人死亡。近四分之三(72.4%)的死亡发生在直升机上,而只有27.6%发生在飞机上。解读NTSB的调查结果,各种人为因素可能导致了87.4%的死亡。这些因素包括飞行员迷失方向、飞行员失误、维护失误、身体机能受损、疲劳或对天气估计错误。与夜间相关的因素可能导致了38.9%的死亡,其次是与天气相关的因素(35.6%)和各种机械故障(17.2%)。
这些数据表明,致命空中医疗事故的可能原因主要是人为因素,因此很可能是可以预防的。建立以人为因素培训为重点的安全第一文化已被证明可以改善广泛医学专业(如麻醉、手术和复苏)的治疗效果。虽然近年来致命事故有所减少,但似乎仍有必要继续强调各种培训方式。