Milne Richard, Costa Alessia, Brenman Natassia
Engagement and Society, Wellcome Connecting Science, Hinxton, UK.
Cambridge Public Health, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK.
Big Data Soc. 2022 Jan;9(1):20539517211070748. doi: 10.1177/20539517211070748. Epub 2022 Jan 11.
In this paper, we examine the practice and promises of digital phenotyping. We build on work on the 'data self' to focus on a medical domain in which the value and nature of knowledge and relations with data have been played out with particular persistence, that of Alzheimer's disease research. Drawing on research with researchers and developers, we consider the intersection of hopes and concerns related to both digital tools and Alzheimer's disease using the metaphor of the 'data shadow'. We suggest that as a tool for engaging with the nature of the data self, the shadow is usefully able to capture both the dynamic and distorted nature of data representations, and the unease and concern associated with encounters between individuals or groups and data about them. We then consider what the data shadow 'is' in relation to ageing data subjects, and the nature of the representation of the individual's cognitive state and dementia risk that is produced by digital tools. Second, we consider what the data shadow 'does', through researchers and practitioners' discussions of digital phenotyping practices in the dementia field as alternately empowering, enabling and threatening.
在本文中,我们探讨数字表型分析的实践与前景。我们以“数据自我”方面的研究为基础,聚焦于一个医学领域,即阿尔茨海默病研究领域,在这个领域中,知识的价值与本质以及与数据的关系一直持续存在且备受关注。通过对研究人员和开发者的研究,我们用“数据影子”这一隐喻来思考与数字工具和阿尔茨海默病相关的希望与担忧的交集。我们认为,作为一种用于探究数据自我本质的工具,数据影子能够有效地捕捉数据表征的动态性和扭曲性,以及个体或群体与关于他们的数据相遇时所产生的不安与担忧。然后,我们思考数据影子相对于老龄化数据主体而言“是什么”,以及数字工具所产生的个体认知状态和痴呆风险表征的本质。其次,我们通过研究人员和从业者对痴呆领域数字表型分析实践的讨论,来思考数据影子“做了什么”,这些讨论表明数字表型分析实践既具有赋能作用,又能带来便利,同时也存在威胁。