All authors are with the University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada. is a Scientist in Health Professions Education, Department of Pediatrics.
is a Research Assistant, Department of Pediatrics.
J Grad Med Educ. 2023 Feb;15(1):24-36. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-22-00180.1.
Graduate medical education is refocusing on the reconciliation process with Indigenous peoples and integrating Indigenous healing practices, cultural humility training, and courses on Indigenous health issues in their curricula. Physicians and all health care workers must be able to recognize, respect, and address the distinct health needs of all Indigenous peoples.
The aim of this scoping review was to explore and describe what exists in the current literature on the impact and challenges associated with Indigenous curricula developed for resident physicians.
The search was conducted using 9 bibliographic databases from inception until April 19, 2021. Two reviewers independently screened for inclusion using Covidence. Three reviewers extracted data and all 3 checked for completeness and accuracy.
Eleven reports were included. Our included reports consisted of qualitative research (n=2), commentaries (n=1), special articles (n=3), systematic reviews (n=1), innovation reports (n=1), published abstracts (n=1), and program evaluation papers (n=2). Findings are presented by 3 themes: (1) Misunderstandings and cultural bias toward Indigenous people; (2) Increasing community-driven Indigenous partnerships to create a safe environment; and (3) Challenges in implementing Indigenous health curricula.
Themes identified related to Indigenous involvement, culturally competent care, common misconceptions about Indigenous peoples, as well as challenges and barriers to implementing Indigenous curricula for residency programs. A collaborative approach involving stakeholders with training in the community is a viable path forward. But comprehensive program evaluation, a source of stable funding, and further research focusing on effective Indigenous curricula for residents are needed.
研究生医学教育正重新关注与原住民的和解进程,将原住民治疗实践、文化谦逊培训以及原住民健康问题课程纳入课程。医生和所有医疗保健工作者必须能够识别、尊重和解决所有原住民的独特健康需求。
本范围综述的目的是探索和描述目前关于为住院医师制定的原住民课程所产生的影响和挑战的文献中存在的内容。
使用 9 个从创建到 2021 年 4 月 19 日的文献数据库进行搜索。两名审查员使用 Covidence 独立筛选纳入文献。三名审查员提取数据,所有 3 名审查员均检查完整性和准确性。
共纳入 11 份报告。我们纳入的报告包括定性研究(n=2)、评论(n=1)、专题文章(n=3)、系统评价(n=1)、创新报告(n=1)、已发表摘要(n=1)和方案评估文件(n=2)。研究结果通过 3 个主题呈现:(1)对原住民的误解和文化偏见;(2)增加以社区为驱动的原住民伙伴关系以创造安全环境;(3)实施原住民健康课程的挑战。
确定的主题与原住民参与、文化上的胜任护理、对原住民的常见误解以及对住院医师课程实施的挑战和障碍有关。涉及利益相关者并在社区中接受培训的协作方法是一种可行的前进途径。但是,需要对全面的方案评估、稳定的资金来源以及关注住院医师有效原住民课程的进一步研究。