Liu Xin, Liu Mao, Wu Bin, Tang Wencheng, Yan Bin, Lu Ruxin
Int J Comput Dent. 2023 Feb 24;26(1):49-60. doi: 10.3290/j.ijcd.b3818301.
The present study aimed to develop a method for measuring 3D maxillary tooth movement during orthodontic treatment and to verify the accuracy of the method.
A 3D model analysis method was established to measure tooth movement by combining the effects of CBCT and intraoral scans. Transformation matrices were used to abstract the motion features of the teeth and translate them into translations and rotations. To test the validity and reliability of the method for clinical application, the inclination of the central incisor was measured using a 3D model analysis method and cephalometric analysis. Measurement error, correlation, and agreement between the two methods were analyzed using the Dahlberg formula, intraclass correlation coefficient, and Bland-Altman analysis, respectively. The performance of the 3D model analysis method was evaluated by monitoring the canine movement of a patient who underwent a premolar extraction.
The measurement error was 0.58 degrees for the 3D model analysis and 2.02 degrees for the cephalometric analysis. There was no significant difference in the central incisor inclination measurements between the cephalometric and the 3D model analyses methods. A high correlation (0.974) and narrow limits of agreement (-3.55 degrees, 4.16 degrees) were obtained between the two methods. Minute movements and additional details of orthodontic tooth movements could be observed using the 3D model analysis method.
The 3D model analysis method was reliable and reproducible for clinical application in monitoring the 3D maxillary tooth movement during orthodontic treatment. The trueness should be further evaluated. (Int J Comput Dent 2023;26(1): 49-0; doi: 10.3290/j.ijcd.b3818301).
本研究旨在开发一种在正畸治疗期间测量上颌牙齿三维移动的方法,并验证该方法的准确性。
建立了一种三维模型分析方法,通过结合锥形束计算机断层扫描(CBCT)和口内扫描的效果来测量牙齿移动。使用变换矩阵提取牙齿的运动特征,并将其转化为平移和旋转。为了测试该方法在临床应用中的有效性和可靠性,使用三维模型分析方法和头影测量分析来测量中切牙的倾斜度。分别使用达尔伯格公式、组内相关系数和布兰德-奥特曼分析来分析两种方法之间的测量误差、相关性和一致性。通过监测一名接受前磨牙拔除术患者的尖牙移动来评估三维模型分析方法的性能。
三维模型分析的测量误差为0.58度,头影测量分析的测量误差为2.02度。头影测量分析方法和三维模型分析方法在中切牙倾斜度测量上没有显著差异。两种方法之间具有高度相关性(0.974)和较窄的一致性界限(-3.55度,4.16度)。使用三维模型分析方法可以观察到正畸牙齿移动的微小变化和更多细节。
三维模型分析方法在正畸治疗期间监测上颌牙齿三维移动的临床应用中是可靠且可重复的。其准确性应进一步评估。(《国际计算机牙科杂志》2023年;26(1): 49-0;doi: 10.3290/j.ijcd.b3818301)