Gul Rani, Tahir Tehseen, Ishfaq Umbreen
University off Malakand, Chakdara, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan.
University of Haripur, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan.
Sage Open. 2023 Feb 16;13(1):21582440231155063. doi: 10.1177/21582440231155063. eCollection 2023 Jan-Mar.
The study investigates the issues of access, quality, and other major challenges to the online system of education for students in Balochistan during this pandemic of Covid-19. Using the mixed-method design, 100 participants from schools and 7 curriculum experts responded to the survey and the interview questions. Survey results suggested that majority of the schools have enough digital devices, and teachers, to some extent, have skills to use technology in teaching, but limited electricity, funds, weak internet connections, and teacher training were some of the major challenges for them. In interviews, the participants showed disappointment in terms of responsiveness of the curriculum because the textbooks have manifold deficiencies in responding to online education. Considering these deficiencies, proposals were suggested to cope with the existing situation. The findings of the study call for the need on the part of the academia, educational stakeholders, and elected representatives to start joint efforts with national and international donor agencies, technology benefactors and telecommunication operators in developing digital infrastructure to provide students with access to education, quality, and lifelong learning through various pathways. The findings can be generalized to other underdeveloped regions both within and across the country, as the public schools are confronting the same issues and the online system of education has not yet been initiated.
该研究调查了在新冠疫情期间俾路支省学生在线教育系统的接入、质量及其他主要挑战等问题。采用混合方法设计,来自学校的100名参与者和7名课程专家回答了调查问卷及访谈问题。调查结果表明,大多数学校有足够的数字设备,并且教师在一定程度上具备在教学中使用技术的技能,但电力供应有限、资金不足、网络连接薄弱以及教师培训是他们面临的一些主要挑战。在访谈中,参与者对课程的响应能力表示失望,因为教科书在应对在线教育方面存在诸多不足。考虑到这些不足,提出了应对当前状况的建议。该研究结果呼吁学术界、教育利益相关者和民选代表与国内和国际捐助机构、技术资助者及电信运营商共同努力,发展数字基础设施,以便通过各种途径为学生提供受教育机会、高质量教育和终身学习。由于公立学校面临同样的问题且在线教育系统尚未启动,该研究结果可推广至国内其他欠发达地区以及全国范围。