Varet Florent, Apostolidis Thémis, Granié Marie-Axelle
Anthropo-Lab, ETHICS EA7446, Lille Catholic University, France.
Aix Marseille Univ, LPS, Aix-en-Provence, France.
J Safety Res. 2023 Feb;84:182-191. doi: 10.1016/j.jsr.2022.10.018. Epub 2022 Nov 3.
Among risky driving behaviors, speeding is a main causal and aggravating factor of road crashes and is more frequent among males than females. Research suggests that this gender gap could be explained by gender social norms that lead males to assign more social value to speeding than females. However, few studies have proposed directly investigating gendered prescriptive norms associated with speeding. We propose to address this gap through two studies based on the socio-cognitive approach to social norms of judgment.
Study 1 (N = 128, within-subject design) investigated the extent to which speeding is subject to social valuation among males, compared to females, through a self-presentation task. Study 2 (N = 885, between-subject design) aimed to identify the dimension of social value (i.e., social desirability, social utility) that both genders associate with speeding, based on a judgment task.
Although results of study 1 indicate that both genders devaluate speeding and valuate speed limits compliance, we found that males do so to a lesser extent than females. Results of study 2 further suggest that males less valuate speed limit compliance than females on the social desirability dimension, while no gender difference were found in valuation of speeding on both dimensions of social value. Regardless of gender, results also indicate that speeding is valued more on the social utility than on the social desirability dimension, while speed limit compliance is valued similarly on both dimensions.
Road safety campaigns toward males could benefit to focus more on enhancing the representations of speed compliant drivers, in terms of social desirability, than devaluing the representation of speeding drivers.
在危险驾驶行为中,超速是道路交通事故的主要致因和加重因素,且男性超速行为比女性更为频繁。研究表明,这种性别差异可以通过性别社会规范来解释,即男性赋予超速的社会价值高于女性。然而,很少有研究直接提出调查与超速相关的性别规范性规范。我们建议通过两项基于社会规范判断的社会认知方法的研究来填补这这空白空白。
研究1(N = 128,被试内设计)通过自我呈现任务,调查了与女性相比,男性中超速行为受到社会评价的程度。研究2(N = 885,被试间设计)旨在基于一项判断任务,确定两性与超速相关联的社会价值维度(即社会期望、社会效用)。
尽管研究1的结果表明,两性都贬低超速行为并重视遵守速度限制,但我们发现男性这样做的程度低于女性。研究2的结果进一步表明,在社会期望维度上,男性比女性更不重视遵守速度限制,而在社会价值的两个维度上,超速行为的评价没有性别差异。无论性别如何,结果还表明,在社会效用维度上,超速行为比在社会期望维度上更受重视,而遵守速度限制在两个维度上的评价相似。
针对男性的道路安全宣传活动可能会受益于更多地关注在社会期望方面增强遵守速度限制的驾驶员形象,而不是贬低超速驾驶员的形象。